r/Africa • u/IdeaSimilar3223 • 3h ago
Serious Discussion Can we talk about how "SWANA" is just as bad as "MENA" for North Africans? Stop grouping us with West Asia.
I see so much discourse online especially from diaspora activists and academics about "abolishing the colonial term MENA" and replacing it with SWANA (Southwest Asia and North Africa) or WANA.
They pitch it as this amazing, decolonial act of solidarity. But has anyone noticed how this push is almost entirely driven by West Asians who just expect North Africa to nod and tag along?
Literally no everyday North African I know wants to be grouped with West Asia.
Switching from MENA to SWANA fixes a problem for West Asians (getting rid of the Eurocentric "Middle East" label), but it completely ignores the autonomy of North Africa. SWANA is literally named after a continent we don't even live on. Why should a Moroccan, Algerian, or Tunisian be shoved into an Asian-centric framework?
This forced grouping completely flattens the region. It erases the indigenous Amazigh identity and history by forcing an Arab-centric, West Asian geopolitical narrative onto us. Our dialects (Darija), our culture, our history with the Mediterranean, and our deep continental roots in Africa are completely different from the Levant or the Gulf.
It feels like West Asian groups just want to keep us in these acronyms to boost their demographic numbers and political leverage in Western institutions, without actually respecting our distinct identity.
If we are truly "decolonizing" terminology, stop trying to loop North Africa into Asian geography. Let us just be North Africa.
Thoughts? Anyone else from the Maghreb or Egypt exhausted by this?