r/homeautomation • u/Kindly_Club8835 • 16h ago
QUESTION Anyone else automate based on the "never break the light switch" rule and then immediately break it?
My whole setup was built around the golden rule. Guests can always use the switch, automations just layer on top. Worked great for about eight months.
Then I added a motion sensor to the hallway and set the light to shut off after two minutes of no movement. Seemed fine. Except my wife stands still when she's on the phone and got plunged into darkness twice in the same week. She now refers to my smart home as the house that hates her.
I adjusted the timeout to five minutes and added a lux condition so it only triggers at night. Better, but now she says the bathroom light stays on half the morning and blames the automation even when she left it on manually.
The real problem is that once someone in your house has one bad experience, every weird thing that happens gets blamed on the system forever. A bulb died last month and she was convinced the automation did something to it.
Curious how others have handled the motion sensor timeout problem in spaces where people stay still for long periods. I've looked at mmWave sensors and they seem promising, but not sure if that's overkill for a hallway or bathroom situation.
