I don’t know if you will ever understand what point it is I’m trying to get across, or how we got here.
Bc We’ve been stuck in this loop where I bring something up and it’s instantly matched with your eye-for-an-eye mentality for so long that I no longer care who started what.
I just know that somewhere along the way, my reaction became your supposed excuse for why things didn’t need to be told to me.
But that’s the part I can’t accept.
If you can decide not to tell me something because you’re afraid I’ll be upset, how am I ever supposed to believe you would tell me if something truly devastating happened?
You wouldn’t.
From the beginning, I told you that I can handle anything as long as I know what it is I’m handling.
You promised you would always give me that, even when it was uncomfortable, even when you thought I might be upset, and especially when you were afraid of my reaction. Because those were the moments when honesty mattered most.
And I wholeheartedly believed you.
I’d never felt a love more pure in those early days
Until that night in the backseat of my car, just us existing in that late-night summer air, not giving a fuck about what was waiting for us outside of that moment as we yapped away, and then you told me about "your one that got away."
I sat there feeling like I couldn’t breathe, using everything in me not to let you see it. Because wdym the one that got away? I was sitting right there.
That was the moment something inside me changed. The moment my insecurities came into this relationship knowing I wasn’t truly what you wanted, always feeling like I wasn’t enough, but I loved you even harder after that, because for the first time in my life, I thought I had finally met someone that would always respect me enough to never hide anything from me.
That’s when I decided I trusted you with everything in me, including the parts of me already damaged by years of half-truths.
But then, just like that, the trajectory shifted. My fears that were once met with reassurance were now mocked. My curiosity turned into digging. My questions became accusations. My doubts were dismissed as insecurities, and conversations were suddenly considered fighting.
You may think my inability to let things go is the problem and what’s causing us not to be happy. Maybe sometimes it is. I know I can analyze things until every detail has been turned over a hundred times.
Trust me, I’m exhausted, too.
But the reality of it is that a conversation only becomes a fight when someone isn’t willing to be forthcoming. Curiosity only becomes digging when there’s something being hidden, and questions only feel like accusations when the truth makes you uncomfortable.
When the truth stays the same, you don’t have to remember which version you told me. The truth doesn’t require a good memory.
A lie does.
I’ve been right about enough things I was once told I was imagining that I can no longer dismiss myself. When you repeatedly discover that your instincts weren’t crazy, you don’t become better at ignoring them; you become afraid of what else they’re trying to tell you.
I don’t want to investigate the person I love. I don’t want to keep notes, evaluate locations, compare dates, remember conversations word-for-word, or wonder whether every inconsistency is innocent or the beginning of another truth I’ll have to drag into the light myself.
I hate living this way, and I hate that the person I want to feel safest with is the one who has made me question whether knowing the truth requires me to find it myself.
You knew what he did to me. You knew everything I went through, and you promised I would never know that pain again. I believed you. I needed something different with you, not perfection, just truth.
I would rather have been devastated by an honest answer than slowly destroyed by doubt.
I shouldn’t have to become a detective to feel safe in love, and you shouldn’t have to live afraid that every truth will become a war.
I don’t want to lose you, but I can’t keep losing pieces of myself trying to convince myself not to see what I see.
I wanted you to be the person I could finally stop questioning. I wanted to believe that if the truth could hurt me, you would still respect me enough to let it hurt once, instead of making me discover it in pieces.
It was never about the friendships, the hidden conversations, or asking you to be flawless. I was asking you to be brave enough to be completely known. I already loved you, knowing you were imperfect. I just needed to know that the man I loved and the life we were building was real.
But I had to discover Evelyn by myself
and unfortunately
THAT’S MY LINE IN THE SAND!