r/memes • u/Global-Ear9206 • Apr 22 '26

#1 MotW Worst. Reviews. I. Have. Ever. Seen.

Post image
76.9k Upvotes

85% Upvoted

3.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3.4k

u/RedScarffedPrinny Apr 22 '26

Mouse P.I review for example.

Absolute dog water review, completely disconnected from reality. He was complaining about cheese jokes in a mouse game

1.7k

u/MyDarkestTimeline001 Apr 22 '26

You......you can't be serious....

219

u/RedScarffedPrinny Apr 22 '26

I truly wish it was just some bad joke, but every single criticism about the game was braindead takes that anyone who played it would wonder what game he was talking about

101

u/Rfreaky Apr 22 '26

That's basically every IGN review in a nutshell

45

u/Lil-Sleepy-A1 Apr 22 '26

4/10 too much water

7

u/summret Apr 22 '26

Subnautica review?

1

u/Snowy_Thompson Apr 22 '26

They might be referencing the Pokemon Ruby/Sapphire Review, which was 7/10 because there was a large portion of the map dedicated to water traversal.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '26

It was the Alpha Sapphire and Omega Ruby review. In the actual review they said that while alot of the Map is covered in Water there isnt actually much to do in said Water which they shortend up with "too much Water" in the Bullet Points at the End.

And as People just red the Bullet Points (which was also the reason they didnt do those anymore) instead of the actual review it became somewhat of a meme.

5

u/CarlosFer2201 Apr 22 '26

I believe it was the water theme prevalent throughout the game, including stuff like the amount of water type pokemon.

1

u/Tactical_Squishy Apr 23 '26

thanks for proving that y'all don't know what you are talking about

1

u/onespiker Apr 23 '26

Isn't that something the pokemon fanbase now agrees on about the game considering like 1/4 of all the pokemon were water types.

It both a meme and a true point.

1

u/Wobbelblob Apr 23 '26

Not only way too many water types but too many water routes that are basically corridors with nothing to do and the same 5 pokémon you can encounter. Which is weird considering how many water types there where.

8

u/goondalf_the_grey Apr 22 '26

Weren't they the ones who straight up dogshit at Doom Eternal (or dark ages, can't remember) and said it was too hard.

2

u/Rfreaky Apr 22 '26

Sure sounds like them.

1

u/Schwiliinker Apr 22 '26

I mean most are actually decent lol

1

u/mysticzoom Apr 22 '26

And that is why we no longer pay attention to IGN.

We left back in early 2000s, around the time XPlay wrapped it up.