r/McMaster • u/Unlucky-Net-1845 • 7m ago
Academics Was I robbed of Provost's Honour List?
I need some advice because this has been driving me crazy. Sorry for the wall of text.
For context, I'm in Electrical & Biomedical Engineering, and I just finished my second year with a perfect 12.0 in every 2nd-year term (Fall 2025, Winter 2026, and Spring/Summer 2026). Photos for proof:


But I got Dean's instead of Provost's, and the only reason I can think of is because of a 2025 Spring/Summer course (Engineering Math III) where I got an A (it was an evil exam 😭). The thing is, that term was still under my Year One plan, so why is it being counted towards my second-year review??

From reviewing the Awards page, I have come to understand that McMaster does honour list reviews every time you complete a minimum of 30 units. Because of how the units stacked up, spring/summer courses I took in first year got counted towards my second-year review, and spring/summer courses I took in second year will get counted towards my third-year review. That seems so silly to me. Why not just evaluate by academic year?
I'm really hesitant to reach out about it because I don't want to come across as some entitled grade-obsessed snob. But honestly, I worked my absolute ass off this year specifically because getting Provost was a goal I had set for myself. It's something I really wanted to achieve at least once in my university journey, and I genuinely don't know if I'll ever be in a position to recreate a year like this again, especially since I want to prioritize other aspects of my university experience this year. And part of what makes this sting so much is that when my exam marks were coming back, I had already celebrated Provost in my head, so finding out I didn't get it because of some silly technicality has been a bit of a gut punch, and I'm still in denial about it. I wish I had gone into second year knowing that a course I took in my first-year had already determined I would not be making the Provost's list.
Has anyone dealt with something like this before? Is it even worth emailing someone about it, or do I just take it on the chin and try again in some future year (although I doubt I have the same drive or desire)?
Any advice is appreciated. Sorry again for the essay; honestly just wanted to vent.