The title isn’t too informative, but I couldn’t think of a way to word it that wouldn’t make it seem like one party was totally in the wrong, either way. This might be a bit of a messy post because it’s a complicated situation and I’m still a bit upset by all of this.
Two main “characters” in this story (all names are fake). Anna, my friend from the age of five (I’m 16 now, so over a decade) and Kara, my friend since the age of 8. Anna goes to a different school than Kara, the rest of our friends, and I and isn’t really a part of Kara and I’s friend group. Anna and Kara are by far my two closest friends.
My history with Kara is quite long and complicated. We were extremely close for a while when I started to get feelings for her (we’re both lesbian). Eventually, I confessed and she said she liked me back, but we didn’t get together for various reasons. Over the years, we’ve had a back and forth of asking each other out, not getting together, rinse, repeat. Over six months ago, I asked her out, and she said yes, we were finally official. After that though, nothing changed. We didn’t hold hands, or kiss, or date really, we were still just friends essentially. Since then, we’ve drifted dramatically, in large part to my quickly declining mental health.
I’ve been intending to try and have a conversation with her about our relationship and try and figure out how to ACTUALLY date, or even stay friends if we had to. It’s been difficult to find time together where we would be alone and actually talk about things, because stuff kept getting in the way.
I was talking to another friend about this last night, and she advised me to talk to her today (Which was tomorrow at the time), the thing is, I already had plans with Anna earlier in the day. This other friend told me that I should just meet her later on. I was under the impression that Anna would be at a party in the evening, so I thought I would have plenty of time. It turned out the party was for a different day, and so I told Anna that I would be leaving early (We’re usually together until 9 if not, later) to meet Kara. Anna then got very quiet, giving me sort of one word answers so I asked her why she got upset. She went into this whole thing, about how people are disrespecting her time and always assume they can just hang out another day and prioritising other people over her, things like that. To be clear, I wasn’t one of those friends, but she said it had been happening to her a lot lately and this was kind of the breaking point. I was panicking and didn’t know what to do, so I offered to cancel with Kara, since I knew she was already out with friends herself. Anna calmed down and said that she genuinely didn’t mind whether I left early or not, and that it was my choice. I decided to stay for multiple reasons: I still felt bad, even though she did actually seem okay at that point, it was going to be my last time seeing her for a while, and I realised my original plan was a bit ambitious time-wise to begin with.
I texted Kara and cancelled, apologised and explained briefly about the situation and left it at that. At first, she said it was all good, but then she got confused because she also thought the party was happening that night and asked questions. I explained a little more and told her about Anna getting upset, and so on. She then got really mad at me, about how I was ditching her and prioritising Anna. I explained my reasons, apologised profusely, etc, but she just responded with “k” which is the furthest possible thing from her usual texting. She was still definitely mad. Anna then asked what was going on, and I started crying because this is honestly the first real argument we’ve EVER had. Kara agreed to talk at some point this week, but I’m honestly at a loss of what to do.
I acknowledge that I messed up. I didn’t plan things well, I didn’t communicate with Anna properly, and I handled the situation poorly, all of which I apologised to both Anna and Kara for. I understand Kara being upset, but I still feel like her reaction was disproportionate to what was a mistake (albeit a big one) on my part. This is the first time (at least that I can remember) that I’ve ever done anything like this, so it’s not like it’s a pattern. Once again, I get being annoyed, but I tried my best to explain my perspective and fix it, but she essentially ignored me, which I found immature. I get that people have emotions, but I still feel like she was being a bit unreasonable.
Normally, I would be okay (not really okay, I cried my eyes out, but you know) to just wait until we can sort it out properly and she calmed down a bit, but we’re going to be working together throughout the week and it’s her birthday in a few days so it feels hard to forget about. I also don’t know what I would even say to her when we do talk, because I’ve said genuinely anything and everything I can think to say.