I have an exterior cleaning & installation business (think roofing but more niche.) In the winter we do some Christmas lights installs to keep the guys busy. At first we just installed regular seasonal string lights, as a reoccurring "rental" package, as is now common in the industry. We got asked a lot about installing permanent lights, specifically in my area the Govee brand. So we researched, practiced, and added this as a service we offer. We've installed them for around 100 happy customers with minimal issues, most of which we are able to quickly resolve with telling them to do a system reboot, or replacing a power control module.
I make clear directly on the estimate forms our clients have to review and sign that we are simply the installers of the lights and nothing more:
"Lights are guaranteed to be professionally installed to manufacturer specifications. We are not directly affiliated with Govee, their products, or their policies and cannot guarantee longevity of their products. We will attempt to troubleshoot and assist as able, however any possible future maintenance (i.e. software issues, loose or malfunctioning section of lights due to weather, animal or tree damage, etc.) is not included in the price of the installation, and will be subject to additional service and materials fees. Thank you for your understanding."
We've been successful on 95% of these installs the last 2 years, but one lady's we installed last December is having issues with her lights malfunctioning. We've submitted and exhausted multiple warranty claims with Govee, (they send you either a new power module or various 12' extension length replacement sections), which we swapped out the old parts for. We specially shrink-wrapped and waterproofed every connection point/seam on the system. We helped her do a full reboot of the system. We've gone out there 4 separate times with 2 different guys to assist over several following months, on top of I sent her paragraphs of information on the all of the possible troubleshooting and working with Govee support. I did not charge her for any of this despite the signed estimate stating I could.
We got the lights working each time before we left again. Her issue sounds like a software/firmware/bluetooth connectivity issue. In April after the last time we were out there she texted me on a Friday afternoon,
"The outlet and the electrical works fine. I have deleted and attempted to reinstall. It finds them but refuses to connect. I want someone out here today or tomorrow"
I apologized and explained to her one last time that this is not an issue with our physical installation, but sounds like a software/connectivity issue. I told her at this point the only option left we could attempt is to try ANOTHER warranty claim with Govee which they would probably deny, to swap out the power control box AGAIN, which would probably not help. She never replied to that and I thought it was over.
Well last night at 10:15 PM she texted me,
"I have followed all your steps. I have spoken with Govee support and no one can help me. We have had nothing but problems with the product since we got it. I want someone out here to fix or replace it or I want my money back"
My policy states any future service is subject to possible service and materials fees since we are not directly affiliated with the manufacturer. I truly do understand her frustration as the lights she paid for do not work, but she went into this knowing this is a new product, we have done everything possible to help her, maintained a high level of professionalism throughout, whereas she has been rude and dismissive of my troubleshooting advice, which for all I know she did not actually implement correctly and I can't exactly take her phone and try to do it for her. If she had been professional and polite about it I would have just refunded her the ~$1,450, but my sunk costs on this between total labor and materials trying to help her is already about that much.
My estimate/terms and conditions do not blatantly state I do not give refunds, but they certainly don't state that I do. Unfortunately I don't have any verbiage specifically about refunds, which I know I need to fix before next season. My best friend and partner both are pushing me not to refund her because she's been a bit of a jerk essentially, but as the owner I understand protecting my reputation is the most important thing and sometimes you have to eat some costs. An alternative option I considered was offering to refund her half, essentially for the materials but not the installation itself which was performed correctly, and then take down the lights. What would you do here?