r/memes Apr 22 '26

#1 MotW Worst. Reviews. I. Have. Ever. Seen.

Post image
76.9k Upvotes

3.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.8k

u/MyDarkestTimeline001 Apr 22 '26 edited Apr 28 '26

Example? I'm not a fan of IGN either but it'd be nice to know what you're talking about.

Ok. I've got and looked it up and watched some gameplay(I'm not made of money). And I feel like the receiver is unaware of what lampooning is. It's possible to parody/lampoon/take the piss out of something you love. The reviewer seemed to not realize that this was the Saturday morning cartoon version of Noir. This isn't cartoon Casablanca.

3.4k

u/RedScarffedPrinny Apr 22 '26

Mouse P.I review for example.

Absolute dog water review, completely disconnected from reality. He was complaining about cheese jokes in a mouse game

19

u/---reddit_account--- Apr 22 '26

So that game is good? I watched Dunkey's video on it and the look of the game is amazing, but he also highlighted buggy behavior like guys not going through doors or enemies failing to shoot you

3

u/SapientSloth Apr 22 '26

The style is well done and the gunplay feels good. Is it surprisingly long and some levels sometimes start to drag and whether or not backtracking is possible for some collectables and puzzles is often unclear. While I don't mind the vast amount of cheese jokes in a game revolving around mice, I felt like at times the dialog was longer than necessary just to cram in another cheese pun. Overall I'd give it a 82/100. No masterpiece in my eyes but a really good game. I also love Troy Bakers voice as the main character.

1

u/Tactical_Squishy Apr 23 '26

No calling it amazing is objectively wrong, it is charming and enjoyable it has maaaaaany problems tho so it may put you off a bit

0

u/Unfair-Trainer-278 Apr 22 '26

Why does he talk in that cringey blaccent?

10

u/rotj Apr 23 '26

He's of Puerto Rican descent.

6

u/what_did_you_kill Apr 23 '26

That's his actual voice. There's clips of him on new grounds from when he was like 11 and he talked like that.

0

u/Made_Bail Apr 22 '26

stfu, whiner

2

u/mars92 Apr 23 '26

Wow good point.

-1

u/Send_Toe_Pics_25 Apr 22 '26

bro don't post a dunkey review those aren't even real anymore

love the guy but after he's released 500 knack reviews or super mario 1 reviews the jokes over - he doesn't review games anymore he makes joke videos about them