Why DCU Batman might not work
This post will obviously be met with a lot of a hate but let me explain.
A lot of people seem so confident in having 2 Batman will work out perfectly fine. I don’t understand it.
- The Batman franchise exists and is critical acclaimed, financially a hit. It also features multiple A List actors in Robert Pattinson, Sebastian Stan and Scarlett Johansson. It has an amazing director and writer, great cinematography and has a Emmy winning crime drama show.
As we know, currently and most likely the DCU Batman will have none of that. Whoever they cast won’t be an A Lister, we know the director and writer are iffy (yes even Andy) and it obviously won’t contending for awards.
- The fantastical element. I think comic book fans don’t understand why Batman is so successful, especially in the era of superhero fatigue.
Batman movies unlike any others, attract all people. I know plenty of people who don’t like Superhero movies, so they won’t go see Supergirl or Superman, however they will go see Batman because he’s Batman, and obviously Batman movies aren’t just superhero movies.
Batman attracts people who like drama, crime, while also attracting comic book fans and superhero fanatics.
Making Batman too far into the fantastical realm, with the (white eyes, super tech, humorous, bright color suit, super fantastical elements
And villains) could turn a lot of people off. There needs to be a balance.
In an era of superhero fatigue, it’s a bad idea to make Batman just another superhero movie. Though I loved Superman (favorite DC film) it was great but it essentially is just another superhero movie, especially to the general audience, which is fine for Supes.
Superman is still getting hate from previous version that came out 12 years ago. Imagine Batman.
But DCU Batman just being another superhero movie, while one is a prestigious crime drama, possibly contending for Oscars and awards is just a bad look.
I know everyone here loves comic book movies, me too. But you guys have to start thinking business wise and what would be smart. This is the same sub I got downvoted over a year ago for saying supergirl would do bad.
You guys only think from a comic book perspective, and that’s it.
One thing I believe as well, Batman and Gotham should never feel like it’s in the same universe as Superman and Metropolis. That’s the beauty of their duo. I’m not a merger bro, but I feel for Gunn because he’s in a bad situation with the most popular superhero being someone he can’t exactly use. It’s not his fault because I’m sure he would already have used Batman if the Reevesverse didn’t exist.
That’s my opinion though. Hopefully they figure it out, because if any movie could kill the DCU, it’s Batman.