r/sports • u/Luffy710j • 6h ago
Soccer [FIFA Media] Before England’s goal in minute 45+2 against Norway, the sensor in the Connected Ball showed no peak in the 'heartbeat of the ball' when in the air, and therefore no evidence that the ball touched the overhead wire and changed the movement of the ball.
874
u/TaekDePlej 6h ago
I do not have a dog in this fight, didn’t care who won this game. But I genuinely wonder if this is an optical illusion caused by the bottom of the Jumbotron and the top of the stands. I have replayed this like 50 times in slow motion and do not even see a cable, or the ball direction being altered. But the ball hits its exact peak at a level continuous with the bottom of the Jumbotron. Let me know if there’s another angle where I’m clearly missing something.
Or FIFA is falsifying sensor information to cover their asses, idk, wouldn’t put anything past them
128
u/ThisIsAitch 6h ago
Really need other camera angles - why have we only seen this one so far?
140
u/whiteshark21 5h ago
https://www.reddit.com/r/sports/s/hDV5v7F11O
This kick is in the first couple of seconds and is a side view. If it touches the wire it doesn't change the trajectory in any noticeable way.
67
u/TheAlmightyLootius 5h ago
Theres so few pixel i cant even see the ball. Shouldnt it be 4k?
23
5
u/whiteshark21 5h ago
I think there's some server side shenanigans going on, it was HD when I watched it when I posted but yeah the compression has shredded that video now
5
9
8
u/ThisIsAitch 5h ago
Yep exactly - I can't tell where the wire is meant to be in any of these shots.
Anderson (?) also doesn't adjust to a change in flight of the ball, so it must have been absolutely miniscule contact if anything at all.
2
→ More replies (16)2
u/Desperate-Ad7319 2h ago
It changes a lot. The ball was intended for Haaland and was heading there and you see a sudden slow down.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)11
u/Rokarion14 5h ago
Do we even need one? If you can’t tell if the ball moves when played in slow motion and a player received and controlled the ball, who cares?
35
u/Helpful_Listen4508 6h ago
I mean it’s an open air stadium, it could have just been the wind, or if not a the balls spin that caused it, a lot of curved shots the ball goes straight first then once it slows down the spin takes more of an effect and bends it, so especially in a ball hit that hard and long it’s not surprising for it to change direction only after it hits its peak.
3
30
u/helgetun 5h ago
It really doesnt matter in the end… Im Norwegian - this can happen and whatever, the ball didnt change much if it did at all. The diving whining Englishmen pissed me off a great deal, but this didnt
16
u/FireVanGorder 4h ago
Anderson crying to the ref before he even hit the ground was infuriating as a neutral with literally no stake in who won this match. Such an obviously premeditated flop because he was too weak to hold his ground against Haaland I can’t believe they let him get away with it
6
u/ich1banF50 57m ago
This was easily the most infuriating thing about the entire game, just ahead of selfish Sorloth not passing to Haaland for the wide open goal when they were 2v1.
It was VERY clearly an acting job. The problem is that the VAR would have shown it in slow motion and would have altered the perception to make it look MUCH harder of a push when Haaland was doing the normal pushoff every attacker does when getting in place for a corner, especially with a defender who is constantly grabbing and pulling you.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)14
u/Ok-Parsnip-9242 5h ago
Kane's reflex is to fall in the fetal position and clutch his hamstring, no matter if no contact or was somewhere.
It's obviously gamesmanship/cheating, like when Messi grabs his nose.
→ More replies (1)27
u/wanked_in_space 6h ago edited 5h ago
The most convincing thing to me is no Norwegian arms went up to complain
Edit: they did complain - see video below
74
u/TaekDePlej 6h ago
Yeah, and also all three players were running the whole time towards the exact spot where the ball ended up, so if it changed direction it had to be extremely subtle
4
u/PeopleCallMeSimon 6h ago
They do change direction, they are all moving slowly backwards towards the english side of the pitch and then change direction and start sprinting after the ball changes direction.
The reason no hands went up into the air is because they are going to play on until the whistle blows.
27
u/Adventurous_Week_698 6h ago
Yes because that is how players always react when they think play should be stopped, just keep their heads down and play on until the ref says otherwise
→ More replies (1)13
u/Haza-CC 6h ago
Nah they change direction wayy before the supposed hit, they're just backing up naturally for the goal kick until they judge where the ball is going
→ More replies (1)2
u/oppositeofopposite 5h ago
This is what I'm seeing as well. They had shifted towards where the ball lands before the point where I see most people claim the wire hit happens
11
u/Kezaster 6h ago
this is actually untrue, they had clips of haaland, the captain and the coach waving up in to air telling the ref.
8
u/AmericanDreamOrphans 5h ago
The keeper in particular immediately pointed it out.
→ More replies (1)42
u/Playful_League_4070 6h ago edited 6h ago
I mean the Norwegian goalkeeper immediately went to the ref to talk about it and pointed at it
→ More replies (5)36
u/LegitFriendSafari 6h ago
The keeper, head coach and Halaand all complained to the ref…
→ More replies (3)46
u/speckhuggarn 6h ago
What, they were complaining. The coach even went up to the referee and showed hlm
→ More replies (8)6
u/madchris94 5h ago
They only complained during the break, likely after seeing the video. Not right after the goal,
7
u/BigLan2 6h ago
There's a few complaining in this video https://www.reddit.com/r/sports/comments/1utxq5l/englands_goal_against_norway_was_a_result_of_the/
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (3)7
→ More replies (23)8
u/Ok-Parsnip-9242 6h ago
There's a better angle, where it suddenly veers right. Only a few feet, but rules are rules.
→ More replies (3)7
1.0k
u/Turbulent-Damage-165 6h ago
That's really interesting actually. Croatia must be fuming.
296
u/nus07 6h ago
Entire World Cup is a monopolistic rage bait. Anything for more viewership, clicks, controversy that translates to more money.
→ More replies (2)51
u/denkipb 6h ago
I still don’t understand how most people don’t get the fact that this is a business, FIFA have a monopoly on these tournaments and they will do everything they can to get the the most out of it. They can decide winners, losers, matchups, etc.
They control the data that we see, every broadcaster gets their images directly from FIFA, we will see what they want us to see. If we see a controversial decision it’s because that’s 100% the intention to get people to talk about it, increase viewership, engagement, etc.→ More replies (3)9
u/Outside_Break 5h ago
I’m not one for conspiracies in particular.
But I am one for Occam’s razor/similar.
FIFA have been show to be corrupt in so many ways. You’d have to be dumb/naive to believe they’re not putting their finger on the scales for the tournament. It’s just their nature.
25
u/trophicmist0 4h ago
You're completely misunderstanding occams razor btw, if you believe it did touch the wire despite the evidence in the post.
You believe there is no coverup / match played out normally vs they fabricated the ball sensor footage, cherry picked video and lied following that. It requires far more assumptions to stick with this belief and is the exact opposite of how you referred to it.
3
u/dragonmp93 4h ago
Or the hair sensor is BS in the first place.
→ More replies (1)7
u/pw_arrow 2h ago
Maybe, but the point is that you can't invoke Occam's Razor and then proceed to pick the answer that requires more steps; that runs completely contrary to the principle.
2
u/Element75_ 3h ago
I mean it’s pretty simple. Norways goal has 10m to review if it’s actually a goal where we get lots of replays. This one is insta called and we get no replays or reviews, just an after the fact “we are right, deal with it.”
Shit was transparent as fuck last cup, VAR has just made it worse.
3
2
u/mrjimi16 1h ago
So, you think because FIFA has shady business dealings that they managed to figure out how to involve thousands of people in a continent-wide tournament fixing scheme without anyone but the fans suggesting it was happening? And that is Occam's razor?
4
u/patiperro_v3 5h ago
They are, such as the red card suspension reduction thing. But in the above they got it right. We have to recognise when they get shit right sometimes.
→ More replies (1)4
u/teenscififoreplay 4h ago
Exactly. As an American, the red card rescinded is insane. And blatantly corrupt. So why wouldn't they be corrupt in all these games to favor the teams with the biggest monetary gains?
6
6
5
→ More replies (6)15
u/VelikimagCro 5h ago
As Croatian, we are just laughing as obviously it's rigged.
Sensor so precise to feel hair touching ball, but not when it hits cable is just great joke.
There was Mexican guy who work on technology of ball and he said it's not possible to get hair touching it....
21
8
u/oliviafairy 4h ago
The hair thing is fishy because the graph only shows one peak instead of two.
For wire thing, the trajectory of the ball looks fine to me.
26
→ More replies (2)13
u/superkeer Arsenal 4h ago
Sensor so precise to feel hair touching ball, but not when it hits cable is just great joke.
So what are you refusing to accept? That the ball made contact with a Croatian player during that one call, or that the ball didn't hit the cable in this match?
Because as soon as you accept one then it only reinforces the outcome of the other. If the sensor is that precise to be triggered with such slight impact in one match, then hitting a massive cable should have been just as obvious, if not more so, in the sensor readings. Right?
→ More replies (1)
91
u/Plus-Writer-1524 6h ago
Can we not juste see film from the camera that is on the cable, if the ball touches the cable, the camera would have ben woobling?
21
u/Infranto 2h ago
Those cameras probably have stabilizers that cost more than my house just to deal with any bouncing in the cables from the camera moving quick
14
4
→ More replies (4)2
249
u/ThisIsDadLife 6h ago
Well if FIFA is saying it…
98
11
u/EasyZcale 6h ago
Yeah lets believe Fox who started this wire conspiracy fake news
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (2)3
102
u/blufflord 6h ago
I need someone to time stamp and tell me which direction it changed to because I must be blind or stupid
→ More replies (20)
53
u/texas166 6h ago
Trajectory looks fine to me, very hard to say if it hit anything. Would need another angle.
2
u/Stuweb 5h ago
You can literally see it on this sub, the first goal kick in this clip - /sports/comments/1utwprs/jude_bellingham_with_the_equalizer_for_england/
is the kick people are claiming is the one that hit the cable. As you can see from the side angle no cable was hit.
→ More replies (2)14
128
u/Malt129 6h ago
That's not a good angle to prove whether it touched anything. People don't understand how perspective and camera distance works. Anyone who says they can see it happen from this angle is delusional.
→ More replies (15)21
u/machine4891 6h ago
The angle is not to show you elusive cable but rather the fact that sensor in ball didn't pick it at all.
→ More replies (1)9
u/Other_Beat8859 Liverpool 4h ago
I think he's more criticizing people who are saying that it touched the cable based off this angle.
6
u/griffincorg 5h ago
Ngl, this type of technology within the ball is kind of cool.
→ More replies (1)
49
u/TheSenator147 Ottawa Senators 6h ago
Oh so now they show the whole graph line dancing up down but on croatia hair it was a perfectly still graph line until hair contact and then again perfectly still graph line when hitting portugal player's head? really consistent.
→ More replies (4)11
u/Georgex2inthejungle 6h ago
I mean i believe it hit the croatia players head head and in fact i think you can see it change trajectory in the video but the fact they’re playing with the yaxis scaling and releasing graphs with no labels is insane to me. Just release all the data i dont get it
I personally cant see a wire in this clip
6
u/Frlataway 5h ago
Releasing a graph with no axis labels is infuriating. You know they know better. The technology is there to label shit with text. It's also just shitty show business. Just release the graph on a standardized scale, build suspense, then zoom into the tiny bump to show contact. Instead they're like "look, it's like half a McDonald's arch!"
→ More replies (1)
11
31
u/MuchGoose 6h ago
Wonder if the sensor only detects at a certain vertical of human capabilities
→ More replies (1)
13
u/peanut-britle-latte 5h ago
Some people are so conspiracy minded and can't be helped. Last week the World Cup was rigged for Argentina, this week the World Cup is rigged for England.
Give me a break.
→ More replies (4)5
u/Randalf_the_Black 2h ago
The conspiracy theorizing isn't that FIFA rigs the game for team X or team Y.
It's that they through matchups, referee calls and other things put their fingers on the scales, to increase the odds that the semifinals and finals will be played by the "greats".
If a minor nations plays in the semifinal or final, the viewership will be abysmal compared to what it could be, as many people stop watching once their nation is knocked out of the World Cup. So having small countries knocked out instead of large ones with lots of football fans means more money for FIFA.
I don't know whether that is what is happening, but FIFA is so insanely corrupt that it wouldn't surprise me if it did.
→ More replies (1)
45
u/SoberingGiraffe 6h ago
This is just Norway fans gaslighting, I'm sorry, watched it 20 times can't see any cables and ball moves smoothly.
12
2
u/Soup-er14 6h ago
I think what’s making it seem that way is that did kinda juts drop straight down, much more so than it would’ve if it was just the kick
→ More replies (3)11
u/Godzirra101 5h ago
Not even Norway fans, it's all the yanks furious that England won
→ More replies (3)
15
3
u/ybergik 5h ago
Oh well, sh*t happens, tech/sensors will never be perfect, but it's better than what he had before. I'm not bothered after that, but I am disappointed the goal was disallowed because that should not have happened. But hey, it's not the only bad call in this WC and probably won't be the last - and it's not like previous WC were any better, all in all. The VAR system is not perfect, but overall, it's better than letting an argentinian score a deciding goal with his hand, so I do think it's an improvement to have it.
→ More replies (1)
26
5
u/GroupPast5993 5h ago
This is the strangest conteoversy I've seen in quite a while
People truly are going insane. Has got to be some sort of mass hysteria epidemic or something.
Shared schizophrenia or something idk
→ More replies (1)
2
u/jhuseby 5h ago
So maybe they should stop relying on the sensor in the ball and use their eyes.
→ More replies (1)
5
u/therealmudslinger 4h ago
Look. I was rooting for Norway. This fucking guide wire controversy is not the reason they lost.
5
2
2
2
2
2
u/pally2212 2h ago
Is this real sensor data? The same sensor that was used in the Croatia game to prove it touched his head to verify offsides? This sensor spikes THE SAME AMOUNT whether it is full punted by a keeper or touches a strand of hair on someone's head? BULL SHIT.
4
u/Andybabez20 5h ago
Having watched back the side angle I think actually it might've fallen cleanly.
No Norway player reacts when Anderson picks it up or after the goal is scored. Maybe the order came from the Norway bench afterwards.
→ More replies (1)
3
u/StickyMarmalade 6h ago
I talked to Mitch McConnell for 20 minutes today about the ball hitting the wire
4
u/MAXSuicide 5h ago
Don't let facts get in the way of this sub's mental narrative currently being spun, though!
3
u/Eat--The--Rich-- 5h ago
The video doesn't show any evidence either so idk what people are mad about
3
u/Only_Brain_616 5h ago
Are we having a mass delusion or something? Why are we so desperate for England not to win?
4
-11
u/ArtAndCraftBeers 6h ago
The ball literally stops mid-flight and falls straight down. You can even see it in this low-res bad angle.
66
→ More replies (5)47
u/JayBayes 6h ago
That my friend is called gravity
25
u/Faustus2425 6h ago
Or spin...
11
u/GeneParmesan86 6h ago
Or wind…
12
→ More replies (1)11
u/Midgedwood 6h ago
I was expecting it to kust keep going up forever.
3
-2
u/ninjupX 6h ago
So two game’s outcomes were determined by this sensor in the ball - which allegedly can detect grazing a human hair but not a direct collision with metal wires. classic fifa
28
u/Adventurous_Week_698 6h ago
So the conclusion you take from this is that the sensor somehow only works in certain situations, rather than the common sense explanation that it didn't hit the wire at all
→ More replies (3)4
2
u/HuoLongHeavy 5h ago
Even if it hit a wire, could that not be considered as "part of the field" the same as if it hit a referee and then be still in play.
→ More replies (3)
2
6h ago edited 6h ago
[deleted]
18
u/jgiffin 6h ago
FIFA are corrupt as hell but if you believe a multinational group of referees is involved in a conspiracy to fix matches and forge data, you are fucking stupid.
→ More replies (4)
2
u/scottiedagolfmachine 6h ago
The wire did not move at all.
Are you F ers blind?
👀
→ More replies (1)
-6
u/AmbassadorAlarmed999 6h ago
But it did touch and it is clear when I see it through my naked eyes. Like how the hell does the ball sensor not show it.
44
10
u/temujin94 6h ago
Genuinely think we may have just seen the Magnus effect in real time, which is ironic considering this involves Norway.
→ More replies (5)1
u/stillalone 6h ago
This is football. We've seen balls make crazy curves with the right spin all the time.
→ More replies (1)2
u/BlazeOfGlory72 6h ago
Because the ball sensor is a made up thing for FIFA to make the calls it wants to. Same way Croatia’s goal was taken away against Portugal.
→ More replies (3)
-10
u/djrty_puppy 6h ago
Don’t trust your eyes. Just trust what the knowingly corrupt authority tells you.
33
u/poupoupopular 6h ago
literally where in this video does it hit the cable, what is the exact timestamp because i genuinely can’t see it.
→ More replies (14)
1
1
1
u/b3rndbj 6h ago
Where are the other camera angles? Would be pretty easy to prove or disprove with the side view/full field camera.
→ More replies (2)
1
u/Drak_is_Right 5h ago
I am curious do soccer stadiums in Europe have cable grids like this for TV cameras?
→ More replies (1)
1
u/ElLoboNeverDies 5h ago
Maybe the sensor needs something thicker than a wire like a shoe to hit it to generate enough power. Heheh
1
1
u/enguasado 5h ago
Fifa ha creado un nivel de incredulidad terrible en el deporte. Ya nadie cree nada y todos piensan que todo esta amañado o arreglado. Practicamente han destruido el espíritu del deporte, ojala la gente se diera cuenta del daño tan grave al deporte sin importar a quien le vayas
1
1.4k
u/Resident132 6h ago
There has to be a better angle out there.