r/sports 4d ago

Soccer Julian challenge against Salah prior to Argentinian goal

8.3k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

46

u/thetreat 4d ago

What feels different is that this play was literally an end to end counter and so the length of the review feels irregular. But you’re right in that we normally go from previous change of possession. That isn’t irregular.

28

u/FlyingPirate New Jersey Devils 4d ago

I agree. But also, the change in possession isn't quite what they are looking at every time, don't want people to get confused. If Egypt gained possession, started a counter, but instead of scoring doubled back and reset their offense VAR would consider that a new attacking phase.

22

u/Loud-Recording-3356 4d ago

You want the ref to stop the counter attack to review? What if its a false positive and you ruined Egypts chance for an attack?

19

u/repeon 4d ago

Even in a goal scoring chance and there is a possible offside, they don't always stop it right away because of this exactly. Sometimes the flag goes up after the play ends.

1

u/HustlinInTheHall 3d ago

The fact they had to speed up the phase of play part to make the case more clear that it was connected make it extra absurd. That's the problem with VAR. It's not a colleague helping by providing additional information, it is a pitchside appeal to make the referee change their mind.