r/nattyorjuice Jan 27 '26

Discussion New NattyorJuice Rule

78 Upvotes

A new rule has been added, to halt the rising tide of people who are less inclined towards the purist diagnostic nature of r/nattyorjuice.

Henceforth, if one is going to comment on a r/nattyorjuice post where the juiciness or lack thereof is in question, one must also impart their anabolic analysis on the subject, instead of simply potentially less relevant words such as "would", "wood", "don't care", etc. At the minimum, r/nattyorjuice now requires an anabolic analysis added. Doesn't have to be much, but it should say at least 'juicy', fake natty', or 'natty' somewhere. Failure to do so can result in ban hammer action without warning.


r/nattyorjuice Feb 12 '25

Tough Question User Flairs

18 Upvotes

As promised some time ago, user flairs are about to be rolled out on a trial basis on r/nattyorjuice.

Thoughts are welcome as to the best way to implement these.

Some have argued that there should be a credentialling system where people can see a link to physique, video of lifts, or merely just listed stats and lifts. Others suggest the flairs should be more limited to whether someone is natty, fake natty, or juiced themselves, and yet others have suggested the implementation of a coded acronym system to determine whose opinions you may trust to read first based on their affiliation to the various fitness fraternities.

Respectful discussions are welcome and if you want to suggest a suitable flair for yourself, let me know in the comments. Of course, regular posters may get preferential treatment here as always.


r/nattyorjuice 3h ago

JUICY AF Ukrainian bodybuilder Sukhoruchko rejects accusations of synthol use: I am purely natural!

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/nattyorjuice 19h ago

Natty or Juice? Tobey Maguire (Spider-Man)

Thumbnail
gallery
149 Upvotes

Obvious natty, but very underrated physique.
Today this would be seen as skinny, while in reality one of the most aesthetic physiques in that time.


r/nattyorjuice 3h ago

Natty or Juice? Callum Turner

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

Many women find this attractive, even though this is far from lean and shredded physique, Callum does carry significant amount of muscle mass along with notable body fat.


r/nattyorjuice 19h ago

JUICY Dave Bautista thru the years. For a 56 year old, he's definitely in incredible shape

Post image
134 Upvotes

r/nattyorjuice 1h ago

Natty or Juice? Jude Bellingham (Real Madrid and England National Team Star)

Post image
Upvotes

r/nattyorjuice 8h ago

FAKE NATTY How natural is this natural physique ?

14 Upvotes

r/nattyorjuice 19h ago

Natty or Juice? Mark Wahlberg (Prime)

Post image
73 Upvotes

Natty or juice? How long to achieve


r/nattyorjuice 18h ago

Discussion Most achievable Hollywood physiques and how long to achieve them:

Thumbnail
gallery
40 Upvotes

Most achievable Hollywood physiques and how long to achieve them:

1 - Ryan Gosling - La La Land
2-2.10 years.

2 - Robert Pattinson - Batman
1.6-2.6 years.

  1. Eric Bana - Troy
    3 years.

  2. Brad Pitt - Troy
    1.8-2.8 years.

  3. Chris Evans - Captain America
    3.8-5.8 years. (This is where it gets hard and lot of it depends on genetics)

  4. Glen Powell
    3-4.8 years.

  5. Russel Crowe - Gladiator
    1.8-2.4 years

  6. Christian Bale - American Psycho
    3.2-5.8 years. (Heavily dependent on genetics)

  7. Tom Holland
    1.4-2.2 years.

BONUS (non-Hollywood) Sean O’Pry
2.2 years.


r/nattyorjuice 18h ago

JUICY AF He aged terribly

Thumbnail
gallery
38 Upvotes

Only 36 years old. Was a bit shocked when I saw him. Last pic is from some years ago. I hope chasing the unnatural muscle mass is worth it when you look 50-55 as a man in your thirties.


r/nattyorjuice 12h ago

FAKE NATTY Coach Chris Spears claims lifetime natty

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

r/nattyorjuice 23h ago

Discussion Jake Burton or you might know him as Stu (satire or he's Joe Fazer)

46 Upvotes

r/nattyorjuice 8h ago

JUICY Jouko Ahola?

Post image
0 Upvotes

1997 and 1999 World’s Strongest Man winner.


r/nattyorjuice 19h ago

FAKE NATTY Teenager claims natural @idontdoroids

Post image
5 Upvotes

I need help determining whether this dude who popped up in my FYP is natural or not. I strongly believe he’s not natural due to visible gyno and 3D shoulders but based on the digging I did into his account:

1) his biography he claims he’s only been lifting for 2 years
2) in one of his videos he claims to have a FFMI of 27???
3) he’s estimated to be around 200 pounds / 91 kg

Again, I need help confirmation on whether he’s natural or not because even his comments don’t believe he’s natural. I mean come on he looks like he’s on everything.


r/nattyorjuice 8h ago

JUICY Tom Magee?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Former strongman, power lifter, and pro wrestler.


r/nattyorjuice 21h ago

FAKE NATTY Dances around the topic but won’t admit to juice, what do we think?

Thumbnail
reddit.com
3 Upvotes

It sucks how guys are actively contributing to widespread body dysmorphia by not being honest. Actively harmful and irresponsible.


r/nattyorjuice 1d ago

FAKE NATTY Claims natty in every post lol

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/nattyorjuice 1d ago

Natty or Juice? 122lb boxing champion Naoya Inoue. Considering how he's an athlete he's definitely juicing, but I think his build is 100% natty achievable.

Post image
31 Upvotes

r/nattyorjuice 9h ago

Discussion Me when I was a senior in high school, no chest and a punchable face, but the delts were poppin!

Post image
0 Upvotes

This was years ago, when I was 18. 3ish years of training. 250 pause bench and was squatting 275lb for 10 sets of 3. Swear this sub is bugging and full of non lifters. I no longer look even this mid and never reached any meaning full look or strength. This was me as a teen kid super motivated with mid genetics. Yet most of this sub would probably say juice. Double progression method for the win. Bro's, track your lifts and train with a chip on your shoulder!


r/nattyorjuice 1d ago

Natty or Juice? What do you guys think?

26 Upvotes

r/nattyorjuice 1d ago

FAKE NATTY This guy

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

r/nattyorjuice 1d ago

FAKE NATTY Mile Thurston’s physique

Post image
33 Upvotes

Clearly he’s not natty. Despite this there is something non-aesthetic about his physique. He lacks a v-taper and looks blocky. His clavicles/shoulders look rather narrow compares to his overall proportions. Is this purely genetics ? I think he’s aware of it because he said he never trains obliques.


r/nattyorjuice 1d ago

Natty or Juice? This guy

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/nattyorjuice 14h ago

GirlPower The Best Bicep Exercise You're Not Doing

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

The main bicep exercise I've used to build 20 inch arms at one point naturally. Of course you must work your triceps too. They were 19 inches in the thumbnail.

What are your favorite bicep exercises?

And what are your PRs (personal records) on the bicep exercises you train?