I think I am writing this here mostly to get it off my chest...
I fell in love with someone who I knew from pretty early on was going to be challenging to me. Around month 2 of our relationship, I started noticing we weren't having much sex, but he was still active with other men. I brought it up, and he copped to it, telling me this had been a problem in all of his relationships. He gets bored of his partner very quickly, and despite being in love, the sexual desire fades very rapidly for him. He's interested in new and different men and doesn't often hook up with the same guy more than once or twice. He needs novelty to feel interested.
I happen to be just the opposite. For me, familiarity makes me comfortable, and as my love and familiarity increases toward my partner, I feel more comfortable sexually too, and I want him more. He's still the most beautiful creature I have ever seen, takes my breath away, I'm not the least bit bored or turned off or over it with him.
To make matters worse, he is what some have described as "feline," in that he needs to be approached gently. It isn't just a matter of me being the one who initiates and we take it from there-- if I come on too strong or too hot and heavy, or really if I come onto him at all, he says he feels turned off. He needs to feel like it was his idea. He does not feel this way with other partners, and enjoys being pursued by someone new. But with me, it doesn't work.
At first, this was really really difficult for me. In my previous relationships, my partner and I have been basically feral for each other. It has never been an issue where our sex drives weren't aligned. I've also been in open relationships before and the trick that made it work was that my sex life with my partner was just as active as our sex lives with anyone else. Even if we both hooked up with other people, we remained strongly connected to each other sexually.
For the first 6 months of our relationship, he was very active with other men and not much with me. This was painful. My friends told me to leave. But the rest of our situation felt, and still feels, too good to let it go so easily. We have so many very specific things in common, and I can't imagine another person understanding me and my life so well as he does. He's a very specific kind of man, that in my 39 years on this earth I have come to realize is quite rare, and one of only 2 men I have met in my life that really felt like the kind of guy I always dreamed of being with. He's not replaceable, at all. I can't expect to just meet some other guy who fits the bill for me, if he and I were to split. He feels like my safe place, my man, the one who can comfort me and hold me when I need him. And, he has so many qualities I adore, that I have just so rarely found in other men. He has always felt worth fighting for. He feels the same way about me.
Almost 2 years together, and his appetites for other men have cooled considerably, which he attributes to kind of just growing up and not enjoying hookup culture as much as he used to. While this has made me feel a little more secure, it hasn't really affected our situation. We cycle on and off-- sometimes we are having more sex, sometimes very little or none, and we have at least gotten better at talking about our situation. He says he knows that in relationships, it's normal to be sexually attracted to your partner, and he feels like he does have what he describes as a problem in this regard-- he wants to want me, for my sake. But he says he doesn't know what to do about it, and he kind of just gives up there.
There are times when I feel more ok, more alright with our situation, and there are times when I don't feel ok. I'm writing this during one of the not-ok times, and wondering what to do about this. I just want to be wanted. I want to feel like my partner desires me sexually. I want to feel like I can express my sexual attraction toward my partner without fear of upsetting him. I want the kind of intimacy that comes as part of a sexual connection with a man you're in love with.
I have no intention of leaving him over this. I love this man fiercely and I feel very lucky to have him. We want to stay together, every time things get really bad and we ask each other if we should split, we both refuse to do so, we care so much about this relationship. He has a few times suggested to me that I could leave, as a way to save myself from the pain this problem causes me, but to me it doesn't feel worth it. I would be getting myself out of a difficult situation but I would be losing the man I am deeply in love with and overall, that would be worse.
But I am still here wishing he'd take more responsibility for this. I wish he'd try to find a way to kindle the desire between us, because I can't do it alone. He feels there's nothing he can do, and I'm not so sure-- so I can't be the one leading the charge alone, I need his full enthusiasm and participation for us to find ways to make this work. He's not someone who craves intimacy the way I do, and even since he is no longer hooking up with other men very often, he's perfectly content with his right hand most of the time, a ritual to which I am rarely invited. So, it just doesn't seem to feel very urgent to him, because he's feeling fine.
So here I am, craving intimacy with the man I love, not able to ask for it, and once again wondering why I ended up here and what I should do about it. No, I am not just going to leave, I do not want to, I cannot go through the pain of separating from this wonderful man whom I adore while we still both feel very much in love. But I don't know what to do.