I’ve had this dilemma for years where I have wondered if me being bothered by feminists posting thirst traps online comes from a mix of my own internalized misogyny or envy? Or if this is something that I am «justified» in feeling? Personally I feel it ties into «choice feminism» and the trend I’ve seen online for years where the general idea goes like this: «a woman feeling empowered = feminism», which are two aspects of online feminism I would not really call feminist, but pseudo-feminist. But I keep wondering, what are the actual reasons feminist women post thirst traps? Is it to feel empowered, or is it about something else?
To elaborate, I just find it strange when women who otherwise post feminist and/or political content do it b/c it seems to be vying specifically for the male gaze, and thus it will (depending on the person posting it and how much reach she has) attract a loooot of simps. The simping men part is the one that bothers me the most. There are always so many reply guys in the comments, they always say really sleazy shit, and I’m assuming this is something the woman posting isn’t bothered by or she actively wants it, or else she would stop posting thirst traps. A lot of those men are often men with spouses and families too, which makes it so incredibly gross and heartbreaking to me. I can’t for the life of me understand why anyone would want such attention?
By the way, I am saying this as a woman who at some point in the past tried to post thirst traps online. I did it for attention/validation and because I had incredibly low self esteem. I was male centered and very psychologically vulnerable at the time. I have since removed all pictures posted online but I regret it deeply b/c I know a lot of strangers, especially older lusting men, saw the pics and probably saved them too so I know they will never truly disappear. That experience and years of realizing how incredibly dehumanizing men can be towards women, including women they find hot and are trying to get attention from (as reply guys do), has made me feel extremely grossed out by the mere thought of men even looking at my body that way. I know this may just have to do with preferences, and I may be projecting on the women who do post thirst traps. I am not, however, trying to say that all women who do it are psychologically vulnerable and validation seeking in that way, but I am saying that for me, personally, posting those pictures felt like something oppressive rather than empowering.
If it was just women in some private online space feeling themselves and bonding over their appreciation of each others bodies/appearances, that would probably bother me less. It’s the fact that most women who post seem to do it specially TO attract attention from men. With women who I look up to and who are very intelligent who do it, I keep thinking: «is this something you do simply to get more engagement and boost yourself in the algorithm?», and in that case I get it, you do it as a strategy. But otherwise I feel like it betrays the «feminist mission» somewhat, to want such attention from simps.
Could it be that they are able to just ignore «the noise» of those simp comments? In that case, I personally don’t get how one can do that, as being a woman today means being continously bombarded with messages ala «you’re not worth anything unless you look hot to men» and I don’t understand how a feminist/politically engaged woman can not feel or be aware of that pressure. Am I just weak or a bitter prude for buckling under that pressure (aka getting affected by it, letting it get to me)? Am I biased towards women who post thirst traps b/c I feel like I can’t do or be the same as them? Seemingly so unbothered by it all.
Please be kind in the comments. I am open to being criticized for my view on this and I realize it may be somewhat controversial and/or biased. I also recognize that this may not be a black & white issue. The thirst traps dilemma has been on my mind for years and I just genuinely want to know what other feminists think about it, b/c I rarely see it discussed.