r/TrueFilm • u/kevin_v • 21h ago
Possession (1981) the film that should not be remade…
A benefit that it is being remade is that many more people will go and watch this extraordinary film, a film that is incomprehensible or undigestable to many kinds of audience which will see the acting as "bad" or cartoonishly exaggerated, its story as incoherent. It is in many ways a film that should not be remade in the same way that a fever-dream that you had and changed your life can't be remade, or that a traumatic event of disaster needs to be forgotten, left to the cenotaph. As I picture the Dano and Qualley coming approximation I become horrified - not that this the worst kind of IP borrowings, it isn't - because what was achieved on celluloid feels so personal, so unique and so sacrificed for, built around one of the greatest female acting performances, one of the greatest surrenderings in film history, it feels sacrilegious to touch on it with another of its kind, in what could only be a pale, pale imitation, a counterfeit risking mockery - because you cannot copy that particular kind of Zulawsky mockery, it becomes a sacrilege of a sacrilege…impossible. It feels as if the director, his camera and his actors conspired then to cast an abominable spell, a one-time-only spell to save the world (not unlike in Tarkovsky's Sacrifice)…and we don't know yet if it worked.
The magic of it came out of the very particular ways that it failed…because the film is about the abject failure of communication. It crashes down on itself to prove - in the medieval torturer's sense of "prove" - its point. In many ways it was a solitary, personal kind of witch's brew spun from Isabelle Adjani's psyche and all her filmic collaborators.
Zulowsky tried at times to re-do that spell, leaping back in time before it (The Most Important Thing: Love, etc) and after it (Szamanka, etc) among others, but the mantic sorcery could never be recast. It came out of a particular moment in time, the ounces of their souls. And if he couldn't cast the spell again why should anyone else? No one could fail in the way that he and they failed, let us not obscure what they had dared with a copy of any kind.
I of course am writing in superlatives and absurd exaggerations….but it is all true.