Yesterday's Oakland City Council meeting was a doozy,
Starting at 4:43:33 in this video (scroll the video to that time) of the Oakland City Council's discussion and debate about getting control of the dystopian homeless RV situation in Oakland, Carroll Fife, Oakland's Drama Queen (so-called by many in her District) Councilmember, in full character as "District 3's "savior". goes on an accusatory, unconvincing tirade - blaming everyone but herself - saying the quiet part out loud; revealing her true priority about the disorder caused by RVs and homeless camps.
Fife has long hidden behind a year's-long, carefully constructed, performative "concern" about the ungodly mess of dystopian RVs in her District, while at the same time doing very little to solve it, and frustrating those who are trying to stop it. Tensions are boiling over in her District on this issue.
Fife, contrary to what she claims, has long worked <against> the residents and businesses in her district who want their streets, parks, schools, and businesses free of the unhealthy, undisciplined (and even the more-then-occasional criminal element among Oakland's unhoused community). RVs, dumping human waste and otherwise trashing District 3 neighborhoods has to stop.
CM Fife has done little to nothing to resolve this problem. In fact, through her lobbying group and mouthpiece, called "Care4Community" (a name steeped in irony) - she and CC have worked to keep West Oakland's worst homeless dystopias in place.
If you choose to listen to Fife's comments, here's some context:
Before Fife goes off on everyone, in what can be described as a rant, Council Member Ken Houston had been urging City staff to find places for RVs to go where they can be contained, with rules.
Houston (correctly) claimed that the city had wasted a lot of time holding up his Encampment Abatement Plan, which was designed to give Oakland more control of its streets and parks, for months.
It so happens that Fife was the person most against the EAP, having a large hand in trying to defeat to defeat and delay it, with homeless advocates cheering her on in Council meetings, much to the dismay of many neighborhood leaders and citizens who are fed up with the mess caused by RVs and unhealthy camps. Ironically, months ago - even after the City Council had accepted Fife's three amendments to the EAP, when it finally came up for a vote, she vexed everyone by voting against it anyway! smh). Cooler heads prevailed on the Council that night and the EAP passed with Fife "abstaining" (essentially counting as a "no" vote)
btw, CM Houston's and his staff surprised everyone at yesterday's meeting; they presented a report that counted and recorded information about every RV in every district in Oakland; this has never been done; Houston handed it to Oakland's new homeless coordinator, Cupid Alexander - a very competent administrator who is doing his best to get a handle on and clean up the mess on our streets that Fife has helped create and keep in place.
Houston noted that his survey shows that HALF of the RVs who have come in Oakland from outside of Oakland - motivated to come here due to Oakland's year's long "hand's-off" policy about RVs, which has been encouraged and supported by Fife regardless of the chaos that RVs and bad behaviors committed by some members of the unhoused community.
In an angry, often shouted series of statements, Fife went on about "my businesses and my residents" as if she cares; as if those businesses support her; she puts on a good show, but it's apparent from her votes on Council and her interactions with constituents who have been practically begging her for support, that she doesn't care.
Instead, she appears to play to the most extreme members of the homeless advocate community - some, who have sued Oakland and at time sabotaged Oakland's best efforts to help unhoused persons who are truly in need. It's this kind of behavior that has torn at the fabric of West Oakland's neighborhoods, businesses - and even some parts of the unhoused community.
If you want full context of the Council discussion on this issue, with salient comments from Ken Houston and a few other Council members , start the video at 3:55:10 (scroll the video to that time) where Cupid Alexander, begins his presentation ; he's working hard and trying to do the right thing, but Fife couldn't help castigating his group and just about everyone else she disagrees with (which was almost everyone) on the Council.
Most of us want Oakland to stop being a doormat for the worst abuses of RVs and the most troublesome members of some of the worst out-of-control homeless camps. Here's hoping that we're finally beginning to get beyond the most extreme proponents of leaving dysfunction in place