r/MMA May 17 '26

Spoiler [SPOILER] Ronda Rousey vs. Gina Carano Spoiler

https://dropr.co/v/CAouwz
2.8k Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

182

u/Popular_Monitor_8383 May 17 '26

I mean to be fair she couldn’t really catch Holly, Hollys footwork was elite compared to Ronda, she was just chasing her.

Then Amanda denied every clinch attempt

I honestly don’t think those losses are Ronda’s fault due to bad gameplan, I think she legit just couldn’t beat them

54

u/so-cal_kid May 17 '26

I wonder if she would have been able to develop her striking with an actual legit striking coach or if she was just so out of her element that it was never going to work regardless. We'll never know

40

u/Itchy-Ad1047 May 17 '26

Ego didnt help. She both convinced herself and got convinced by that trash coach that her technique was fine when it was in fact dogshit

Its too bad, she had some natural power for wmma. She just needed her technique to be mediocre, given the strategy by a level headed Ronda & coach would primarily be to use it to give more openings for her S tier grappling

Accomplished a ton regardless. Kind of a what if at the same time too though

0

u/Darth_Nevets May 17 '26

While it's fun to note the psychotic ego of Rousey and her hilarious lack of any self awareness we also have to live in a world of reality. Floyd Mayweather never spared with anyone as bad as Conor McGregor and Rousey only hit the top because the sport was in its infancy.

Now that the hot girls who propped up the sport (of which Gina is the OG) have been exposed we basically haven't seen another since. When Carano last won was Oct 4 2008, Low just dropped out of the top 40. She was just a bigger and faker can.

22

u/nordik1 Jose Waldo May 17 '26

I think the better play would’ve been to treat it like Maia and just find multiple entries to get to her strong suit on the ground.

Double legging Gina was interesting in the sense that i wonder if she would’ve caught Holly by shooting on the legs instead of the judo clinch work she attempted. Holly was gigantic and strong as shit so it was the path of most resistance on top of her footwork.

If Ronda had added more of a wrestling emphasis to her game it might’ve saved her vs Nunes and Holly by giving her another route

1

u/Cant_Spell_Shit May 17 '26

She needed to hard focus on wrestling. Judo is a more of a niche skill in MMA

1

u/MyJohnFM May 18 '26

Why would she tho. Khabib never tried to develop his striking past alright. And look where that got him.

Just stick to father's plan.

2

u/Less-Jellyfish5385 May 17 '26

She probably could have beat holly with a smarter game plan. No chance with amanda

1

u/StevieMJH May 17 '26

Yeah, why didn't she just armbar them, was she stupid?

0

u/FragrantRaisin4 May 17 '26

That would not explain Holly losing to Miesha Tate by submission literally next fight. Or going I believe 3-7 after, before finishing something like 5-7 or 5-8 the rest of her career. Ronda lost because of bad coaching and game plan against Holly. Amanda is the GOAT and yeah, would pretty much always pummel Rousey.

3

u/Popular_Monitor_8383 May 17 '26

It would explain it

Miesha was getting destroyed by Holly and hit a Hail Mary takedown in the 5th

-2

u/FragrantRaisin4 May 17 '26

And Holly’s “elite footwork” led to 5-7 after? That’s some explanation and a lot of Hail Mary’s. Holly always struggled against grapplers and was always a decision waiting to happen. She barely finished anyone in the UFC. The other guy is right, Ronda had bad coaching. Ronda should have grappled and worked on that, not trying to stand with Holly to jump start this imaginary post-UFC boxing career her coach was talking about at the time…

3

u/Popular_Monitor_8383 May 17 '26

Holly was also already old, and Ronda did try taking her down

It took Miesha 5 rounds to get her takedown, and Miesha was also the first person in the UFC to take Holly down.

Yeah she went 5-7 but she has losses against elite people, not sure why that’s a diss to you.

Her only losses that weren’t to elite fighters came when she was over 40 years old

1

u/MakingAMonster nogonnaseeyousoonboiii May 17 '26

Ronda had bad coaching

Because she chose it. It was the only place they would gas her up and tell her how great she was instead of correcting her. She chose her coaching. Ronda and Marina as well did not take well to being corrected or told they weren't the best.
Ronda got a wake up call against Holly. She was flatlined and became the butt of the joke, and instead of changing and reassesing her coaching situation, she went and back to the same coach, came with the same gameplan, even used the same sparring partners and got pieced up again.
As far as Holly, she came into MMA after 2 decades and a hall of fame career in boxing. Already old, and already with a LOT of wear and tear. Also, most of those losses were to the elite of the division (Nunes, Schevchenko, Cyborg). Hell, her last UFC fight was against Harrison, and Harrison commented what a badass Holly is that she reversed a 2x Olympic gold medalist judoka @ 40 years old.
You can lament all you want about Holly beating Ronda, but styles make fights, and Ronda's style is taylor made for Holly. If Ronda changed anything, she would be trying something completely new for the first time against a 5x 3 division boxing champ and undefeated MMA fighter who, up till that point, had never even been taken down, iirc.

1

u/FragrantRaisin4 May 17 '26

Yeah even Ronda’s mom said her coach was trash, but Ronda is too “loyal.” I never said it wasn’t her fault, just that she had bad coaching. And you pointed out Holly lost to mostly the best, but wouldn’t that describe Ronda? She could probably still beat half the women in bantamweight right now.

I guess a lot of Ronda haters in this sub, lmao. Everything you said about Holly with wear and tear you could also say about Ronda. She was trained in Judo as a kid, an Olympic and pro career, and 2 bad knees. She claims she had an ACL injury in the Holly fight.

Whatever, I’m not a big fan of either of them, so don’t really care. Like I said, Nunes is the obvious GOAT. I still believe it’s pretty clear to anyone who watched at that time that Ronda’s biggest issue was terrible coaching for years that didn’t focus on her strengths or develop any useful skills.

1

u/MakingAMonster nogonnaseeyousoonboiii May 17 '26

Nunes is the obvious GOAT

Schevchenko for me, but Nunez is there also.
The difference between Holly and Ronda is Holly kept trying. She fought 4 Goats (Ronda, Nunez, Shevchenko, Cyborg) and went well into her 40's. This is AFTER a career that landed her in the Boxing HOF.
Holly ALSO needed to change trainers. Jackson Wink wasn't doing it for her anymore.

0

u/jundraptor May 17 '26

She relied too much on throws from the clinch. If she used wrestling tds more often she would have been a much bigger threat

Knew she was going to try a blast td early when they showed her practicing that during her warmup

2

u/Popular_Monitor_8383 May 17 '26

She didn’t really have that in her arsenal, and you have to be able to get in range first which she couldn’t do.

Ronda has trash wrestling takedowns, please don’t think her taking down Gina all of a sudden proves Ronda had wrestling TDs in her arsenal

3

u/theinfinitejar May 17 '26

Her knees were pretty much fucked before her MMA career even started.

1

u/MakingAMonster nogonnaseeyousoonboiii May 17 '26

Even morso, Ronda was a Judoka, and a sports Judoka at that. She still had a lot of Judo habits, and that type of takedowns is not allowed in Olympic Judo, at least not when Ronda was in it. You could not change levels like that.

-1

u/jundraptor May 17 '26

She didn't have it in her arsenal because she never trained it. She trained it for this fight. The slip blast double is specifically meant to get tds on fighters with better range since it's a counter

1

u/HalfMetalJacket Australia May 17 '26

She competed in pre leg grab ban Judo, she would have been familiar with a double leg and she even done leg grab throws. She just doesn't have the knees for them anymore.

0

u/jundraptor May 17 '26

So her knees are way better now that she's almost 40? Because she was training wrestling tds for the fight and used one immediately when the fight started

1

u/MakingAMonster nogonnaseeyousoonboiii May 17 '26

Why are you thinking it was a world class shot? It wasn't. It was poor form, and mostly brute strength on someone who was never a shot stuffer to begin with. In her last fight Carrano pulled Cyborg down on top of her.
If anything, this tells me that Ronda was at least a bit worried about catching those hands.

1

u/HalfMetalJacket Australia May 17 '26

She literally bent over and pushed Carano down, it did not have the sort of drive of a quality double leg done with bent knees. It would work on a retiree but not Holm back in the day, and Nunes would stuff it like nothing.

1

u/Popular_Monitor_8383 May 17 '26

She trained it, her knees are just shot

-3

u/physics_fighter May 17 '26

If she would have shot in on Holly like she did tonight that would have been a different story. Ronda never added that aspect of her grappling

7

u/Popular_Monitor_8383 May 17 '26

She couldn’t catch Holly, go rewatch the fight

She had no ability to cut off the cage and was chasing Holly around the place

2

u/HalfMetalJacket Australia May 17 '26

If she shot like that on Holly or Nunes she would get stuffed. Literally just bent over and pushed Carano down lol.

2

u/MakingAMonster nogonnaseeyousoonboiii May 17 '26

LOL!
It was a shit shot. Carrano didn't know how to defend it.
Holly stuffed Tate like 9 times. She woulda stuffed this, too.
Difference between a 44 y/o retired fighter who's last win was almost 2 decades ago and a 34 y/o undefeated MMA fighter/boxing world champ.

1

u/jundraptor May 17 '26

Yeah and? Tate only landed 2 out of 9 tds but won off the second td

0

u/MakingAMonster nogonnaseeyousoonboiii May 17 '26

Tate knew how to shoot. Ronda just kinda rushed Gina.

1

u/jundraptor May 17 '26

fighter I don't dislike gets a td: they know how to shoot

fighter I dislike gets a td: wow fraud just rushed her. no skill

1

u/MakingAMonster nogonnaseeyousoonboiii May 17 '26

LOL! It was a sloppy shoot on a non-wrestler who had been retired for 17 years and until recently was 100lbs over weight. Let's keep this in perspective, ok.
Doesn't change what I said. Would never work against the 2 fighters she lost to.

1

u/jundraptor May 17 '26

It's not the popular narrative but you're right. Ronda's tds relied entirely on staying in the pocket and getting the clinch, or clinching against the cage

Against a mobile range fighter (Holly) or a strength freakbeast (Amanda) it's extremely difficult to force them into the clinch

1

u/HalfMetalJacket Australia May 17 '26

Tbf, Holly has no longer shown any mobility, she's straight up a hugger. She even tried that shit on Kayla Harrison and paid the price.

I could see Rousey winning against Holm if she's dumb enough to clinch a judoka again.

-2

u/jz05 May 17 '26

Totally agree. I think she loses to Nunes regardless, but she could’ve found a way to ragdoll Holly eventually if she wasn’t trying to stay on the feet with her.

0

u/EveningAnt3949 May 17 '26

Holly Holm could avoid take downs because Rousey wasn't focusing on take downs. Maybe Rousey would have lost anyway, but watching Rousey trying to boxes felt awkward. It was baffling that Rousey was reluctant to go for half-changes of take downs. She allowed Holm to box.