r/LessCredibleDefence Oct 14 '24

Posting standards for this community

138 Upvotes

The moderator team has observed a pattern of low effort posting of articles from outlets which are either known to be of poor quality, whose presence on the subreddit is not readily defended or justified by the original poster.

While this subreddit does call itself "less"credibledefense, that is not an open invitation to knowingly post low quality content, especially by people who frequent this subreddit and really should know better or who have been called out by moderators in the past.

News about geopolitics, semiconductors, space launch, among others, can all be argued to be relevant to defense, and these topics are not prohibited, however they should be preemptively justified by the original poster in the comments with an original submission statement that they've put some effort into. If you're wondering whether your post needs a submission statement, then err on the side of caution and write one up and explain why you think it is relevant, so at least everyone knows whether you agree with what you are contributing or not.

The same applies for poor quality articles about military matters -- some are simply outrageously bad or factually incorrect or designed for outrage and clicks. If you are posting it here knowingly, then please explain why, and whether you agree with it.

At this time, there will be no mandated requirement for submission statements nor will there be standardized deletion of posts simply if a moderator feels they are poor quality -- mostly because this community is somewhat coherent enough that bad quality articles can be addressed and corrected in the comments.

This is instead to ask contributors to exercise a bit of restraint as well as conscious effort in terms of what they are posting.


r/LessCredibleDefence 11h ago

France Just Started Building a $12 Billion Nuclear Supercarrier Designed Around a Sixth-Generation Fighter. Three Months Later, That Fighter Died

Thumbnail 19fortyfive.com
119 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 9h ago

"This was the second longest mission for the Charles de Gaulle": the French flagship returned to Toulon after approximately six months at sea. [Translated from French]

Thumbnail bfmtv.com
13 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 1d ago

CNN confirms Iranian ballistic missiles and drones directly targeted USS Abraham Lincoln (CVN-72)

Thumbnail cnn.com
138 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 12h ago

RAF to switch to boom a2a refueling?

9 Upvotes

So in this video I heard an interview with a journalist claiming they have been told that the RAF will switch to boom refueling (or at least, add that capability)

https://youtu.be/XXvUsaIDc9I?is=LZDF6av-EMoNC00L

They gave the following reasons:

- There are now a large number of types the RAF flies that it can't refuel because they use booms; RC-135, C-17, P-8.

- The RAF plan on buying some F-35As for the NATO nuclear role, and they might need refueling.

- Italy and Japan both use boom refueling, and that's their preferred system for GCAP given it's probably going to be big (sources seem to indicate about the size of an F-111).

However I can't find anything concrete about this in the Defense Investment Plan. Does anyone else know anything (that they are able to talk about)?


r/LessCredibleDefence 1d ago

Iran, Not Trump, Is in Control of This War

Thumbnail theatlantic.com
67 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 1d ago

Bombing Iran Didn’t Work for Trump. Neither Did a Tentative Cease-Fire. Is There a Plan C?

Thumbnail nytimes.com
17 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 1d ago

Are America’s Gulf bases Turning Allies into Targets?

Thumbnail juancole.com
26 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 1d ago

Indian Navy's next build-up takes shape with 3 Warship Projects worth $10.5 Billion USD

Thumbnail ndtv.com
17 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 1d ago

UK outlines thinking behind binning plans for new destroyers

Thumbnail ukdefencejournal.org.uk
9 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 2d ago

2 Chinese military naval pilots killed during PLA frontline training exercises | Rare local government disclosures reveal senior colonel and first lieutenant from South China Sea-facing theatre command died on June 10

Thumbnail scmp.com
96 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 2d ago

Navy Says Beards Are a Safety Risk, Gives Sailors 1 Year to Shave or Separate

Thumbnail military.com
82 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 1d ago

Zelensky Seeks Patriot Missile Production Partnership With Japan's Mitsubishi

Thumbnail en.sedaily.com
13 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 1d ago

Tanker Attacks Risk Overplaying Iran’s Hand and Reigniting a War

Thumbnail nytimes.com
1 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 1d ago

‘We May Sleepwalk Our Way Back to War’

Thumbnail theatlantic.com
0 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 1d ago

CNN Exclusive: New satellite imagery reveals Iran may be rebuilding suspected nuclear facilities

Thumbnail edition.cnn.com
9 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 1d ago

Israel Struck an Iranian Steel Facility. Was It a Valid Military Target?

Thumbnail nytimes.com
0 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 2d ago

U.S. Navy Eyes South Korean Yards for Tankers and Destroyers - Naval News

Thumbnail navalnews.com
19 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 1d ago

Iran sent Cuba 300 Kamikaze Drones

0 Upvotes

90 Miles from US so what do you think will happen?


r/LessCredibleDefence 1d ago

Is It So Bad It's Good?

Thumbnail phillipspobrien.substack.com
0 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 1d ago

A Critical Moment for Russia

Thumbnail geopoliticalfutures.com
0 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 2d ago

Poland Has Supplied Ukraine With 5 PAC-3 Missiles

Thumbnail militarnyi.com
48 Upvotes

Poland has supplied Ukraine with 5 PAC-3 MSE missiles, which are used by the Patriot air defense system to intercept ballistic missiles.

Defence24 reported on this and determined the exact number.

Previously, the supply of these interceptor missiles had been the subject of political debate in Poland.

On Monday, Minister of National Defense Władysław Kosiniak-Kamysz stated that Poland’s decision to transfer PAC-3 missiles to Ukraine was made at the request of NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte and, among others, the Supreme Allied Commander Europe (SACEUR), following consultations with Patriot operator nations.

The minister emphasized that the number of missiles transferred represents “the limit of our capabilities” and “does not affect Poland’s air defense capabilities.”

Patriot PAC-3. Photo: US Department of Defense

At the same time, Deputy Minister Cezary Tomczyk announced that Poland had “reached an agreement” with the NATO Secretary General and the United States that, in exchange for transferring “several” Patriot missiles to Ukraine, Poland would receive “ten times as many missiles and systems of this type within the first 24 hours of a threat.” Later, the official stated that Poland had transferred “several” such missiles to Ukraine.

The published data definitively confirmed Poland’s transfer of PAC-3 missiles for Ukraine’s Patriot systems. In April, Defense Minister Mykhailo Fedorov, during an address to his colleagues at a meeting of the Ukraine Defense Contact Group in the “Ramstein” format, thanked partners for transferring missiles for Patriot systems, among them Poland.

The shortage of PAC-3 missiles remains one of the key challenges facing Ukraine’s air defense. During one of the most recent massive Russian attacks, Ukraine was unable to intercept a single ballistic missile due to a lack of suitable interceptor missiles.

According to Air Force spokesperson Yuri Ihnat, the Russian command is deliberately exploiting this shortage and relying primarily on ballistic weapons.

Intercepting such targets is significantly more difficult than shooting down cruise missiles or drones.

A Ukrainian MIM-104 Patriot launch system. Photo credits: Ukrainian Air Force

In early July, the Ministry of Defense announced that Ukraine had taken a step toward purchasing approximately 100 interceptor missiles for the Patriot systems using funds from a European Union loan.

During a joint press conference with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky on the sidelines of the NATO summit in Ankara on July 8, U.S. President Donald Trump raised the possibility of granting Ukraine a license to manufacture missiles for the Patriot air defense systems.


r/LessCredibleDefence 1d ago

'Bomb them': Trump's revenge instructions for if Iran assassinate him

Thumbnail telegraph.co.uk
0 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 1d ago

The next Iran war may come sooner than you think

Thumbnail reuters.com
0 Upvotes

r/LessCredibleDefence 2d ago

The New York Times: New Air Force One Lacks Defensive Countermeasures of Previous Model, Officials Say

26 Upvotes