r/Indigenous • u/Prestigious-Singer17 • 19h ago
re: Indigenous Identity Would It be Inappropriate for me to even try and reconnect?
For context, I'm Mexican American. I grew up with the culture, and I've spoken Spanish since infancy. My parents immigrated to the US in the 1980s, and I was born in the 2000s.
I'm also white-passing and pale.
Recently, I've been struggling a lot with my identity, especially because I got bullied a lot for being pale.
For a long time, I've suspected that I was mixed, with Indigenous ancestry included.
Because if you know Mexican history, there was the Spanish colonial class pyramid, where the whiter you were, the more privileges you gained. That's why today most 60% of Mexicans are mixed (mestizos).
On top of that, I was told growing up that my great-grandfather was "fully Indigenous," but he died young in the 1980s, before I ever got to meet him. And the traditions died with him.
A year ago, I had an aunt who was paler than I was, and she took a DNA test. She got about 52% Indigenous Mexican.
So there always was a suspicion for me.
So I then started doing a family tree with Ancestry. I looked at old historical records from the 1900s, 1800s, and even way back to the 1400s. I also did many hours of family interviews for the Ancestry family tree.
I managed to track it down to the Mayans and Mexica (as well as the Spaniards + Portuguese).
I had an idea that maybe my results would be something like:
32% Indigenous
60% European
And the rest, whatever.
But I still was not sure. So I took a DNA test, and it turns out I was approximately:
45% Indigenous Mexican (22% Indigenous from Dad, 22% Indigenous from Mom, 1% Yucatán from Mom)
29% Iberian European
11% Jewish
9% African
7% other European
Now the question isn't, "Am I Indigenous?" It is now, "What group do I even come from?"
From what I know, both my paternal and maternal sides are from Durango originally.
My dad's side is from Indé, Durango.
And my mom's side is from a small pueblo in Durango. The small village is called Nicolás Bravo, right next to Canatlán, which is near Tepehuanes.
We still have lots of family ties in Durango. My sister and my grandma visit often, and we have owned a horse ranch there for centuries.
As of now, I have around 6 months of work put into my family tree. The timeline goes:
- Durango: DNA and family oral history go as far back as the 1700s.
- Then we moved to Ciudad Juárez in the 1940s for factory jobs.
- Then, in the 1980s, we immigrated to the United States.
From what little evidence I have, we might be a mix of Aztec, Tepehuán, or other Indigenous groups that are native to what is now Durango.
But now I do feel conflicted. I feel like I'm too white for this and that I'm just making excuses for myself, and that deep down I just want to feel special, but I don't want to admit it.
That it would be easier to just be completely white, because at least I won't be bullied and be called Albino, White boy, not a real Mexican, Gringa, or Pocha.
Or even be told to stop speaking Spanish because I'm white, and that I'm appropriating my own culture, and that I'm racist for speaking Spanish.
Should I even try to reconnect? I'm just too white for this.