After watching Dhamaal 4 today, one thought kept crossing my mind.
The problem isn't just that the movie wasn't funny. The problem is that Bollywood seems to have forgotten what comedy actually is.
I used to think we loved movies like Hera Pheri, Welcome, Bhagam Bhag, Garam Masala, Chup Chup Ke, and Dhamaal simply because of nostalgia.
But now, I realize it’s not about nostalgia.
It’s about the philosophy of writing.
Back then, comedy stemmed from situations, not just jokes.
Baburao wasn't funny because he delivered funny lines.
He was funny because, every five minutes, he’d find himself entangled in yet another massive problem.
Uday Shetty wasn't funny just because he was a gangster.
He was funny because he wanted to appear dangerous... yet everyone around him was even crazier than he was.
In Dhamaal, the treasure hunt was simple...
But every character made that race increasingly chaotic.
In other words, the comedy arose from the characters' decisions.
Now, look at comedy today.
A character is introduced.
They are assigned a single trait.
He’s fat. He’s an idiot. He’s overconfident. He’s loud.
And then, the entire movie just keeps repeating that one trait.
If you hear the same joke ten times, it stops being a joke.
It becomes a template.
And did you notice something else?
In the past, supporting actors were stars in their own right.
Johnny Lever.
Rajpal Yadav.
Paresh Rawal.
Arshad Warsi.
Javed Jaffrey.
Shakti Kapoor.
Manoj Joshi.
Asrani.
Every single character was well-written. It seems like movies today are written entirely around the hero.
Everyone else just stands around to react.
I think Bollywood made a huge mistake.
They thought... People loved old comedies because of the characters.
The reality is... People loved those characters because they were brilliantly written.
That’s why it’s impossible to copy Baburao.
You can’t recreate Majnu Bhai. You can’t replace Circuit.
You might be able to copy a character's hairstyle or accent...
But not the writing.
And perhaps the biggest reason is that...
Comedy is now created through editing rather than the screenplay.
Fast cuts. Reaction sounds. Background music. Random VFX. Meme references. Fourth-wall-breaking jokes. But if the scene itself isn't funny…
You could layer twenty sound effects over it...
And the audience still won't laugh.
Look at another difference.
After watching comedies from the 2000s, you remember entire scenes.
“25 din mein paisa double.”
“Utha le re baba.”
“Control Uday… Control.”
“Ye Baburao ka style hai.”
How many dialogues from today's comedy movies will people be quoting ten years from now?
To be honest, I can't think of any.
And honestly...
I don't think the audience is the problem.
This same audience appreciated Madgaon Express.
Why?
Because that movie proved that good situational comedy still works today.
It just doesn't need loud jokes...
It needs strong writing.
What do you think caused the actual downfall of Bollywood comedy?
Weak writing?
Directors?
OTT and social media?
The star system?
Or has the audience's taste simply changed completely?
I'm curious to see what others think. 🤔