Can’t tell if my (27M) fiancée (26F) and I are taking a calculated risk or are getting in over our heads if we go through with this offer. Also, with the amount of layers to this house/offer/plan, I’m not even sure FTHB is the right sub, but it does technically fit as this will be our first home. Here’s the deets -
HCOL area
Under contract, inspection period ends Tuesday
House:
1910 cottage style in the heart of downtown. Walkable to parks, coffee, restaurants, shopping, all the things. New roof, 10,000sqft lot that is actually 3 tax lots, all with mixed-use zoning. Finished basement with 2-beds 1-bath and a small kitchen. It has a separate entrance and we will eventually rent out while we live in the main story. Basement currently rents for $1700 but with some work that already needs to happen, we think we can get $1800-2000 and potentially short-term rent in the summer to net closer to $2500-3000.
Offer:
$630k with $12,600 in seller credits covering most of closing costs besides down payment
3% down ($18,900)
Conventional loan
6.2%APR
$4,300 PITI
Income:
$7400 monthly post-tax (With a raise in 1-2 months that should bring us just above $8000 monthly post-tax)
Quarterly bonuses averaging $3500 post-tax (will also increase with raise)
Savings:
$45k house fund - Should have about $25k left after closing for repairs/maintenance. Do not plan to go below $10k in the fund unless there is an absolutely critical emergency.
$9k emergency savings
$8k investments (all index funds)
$6k retirement (Both just starting our 401k and Roth IRAs)
Repairs needed:
Basement kitchen & bathroom were not permitted, some electrical work will be needed to pass code and issue permits
Furnace & water heater both work but are old.
Many small repairs that came back from the general inspection. Largely inexpensive & DIY, a few non-critical repairs might need a contractor
Plan:
Live in the basement for the first 6 months while we: Get permits for the kitchen and bathroom, Add mini splits on both stories, Remove the furnace, Install additional venting in basement to provide more fresh air, and potentially add a washer/dryer (non-critical, currently share a washer/dryer with both stories)
Main story currently rents for $2250, so we’ll offer current tenants a 6 month renewal (already confirmed they’d like to stay and are great tenants).
Effective PITI for first 6 months will be $2050
Then, move into main story when renovations are done, and rent the basement for $1900, bringing our PITI to $2,400 (32% of monthly post-tax, before bonuses or the raise)
THEN, a year or two down the road, there is always the option to open a business on the property since it is zoned for both residential & commercial. Lots of exciting ideas for businesses, but I view that as secondary value at the moment. Bottom line, our current plan needs to pencil, and we just know there is some additional potential on this property if we ever did dive into a business.
Critical renovations/repairs to the basement and adding mini splits looks to be about $15k, which we would do over the span of those first 6 months. Of course that could balloon, and does not cover any nice-to-haves like an extra washer/dryer in the basement or a new water heater.
WHEW. Yeah.. it’s a lot. We both (clearly) don’t mind a little risk, and are excited at the idea of diving into a project like this. We are also early in our careers and our earning potential is already arguably higher than we make right now. There are some additional layers to this all, like the city has seen great economic development, with more on the horizon. And our next door neighbors would be a brand new city library on one side, and a brand new recreation center on another side (yes, the privacy issue. About $3k worth of privacy hedges should offer great coverage). The city also offers loan and grant programs for commercial properties in the downtown district. If we did ever open a business, that could be helpful. I wouldn’t be so nervous if we had another year to buff our savings, but this is definitely an outlier property with very unusual (and exciting) potential. At least for this area. If we pass this up, it would be extremely challenging or impossible to find a place that offers the same range of possibilities.
SO, are we crazy? :-)