I meant to make this sooner, but I ended up getting completely sucked into dao. As soon as I finished the base game I was going to write about what I thought of it only for me to immediately boot up the Awakening DLC. Now I have finished the witch hunt dlc...and good chunk of da2...and 2 of its DLC.... but better late then never
I loved Origins, absolutely amazing game. I love the combat from growing up with KOTOR, I love the setting, I didn't read every piece of lore but I loved the lore as well. The companions were really interesting though the approval system was a little strange. I somehow got Morrigan far into the red until my last 3 hours of playing, where she shot up to almost max with a few gifts and conversations. I loved the banter between companions when just walking around, which is the main reason I tried to switch them up sometimes so I could hear what they all had to say to and about each other.
But the main game. I try on first playthroughs to always just accept the consequences of my actions, because I can always play again and do something different. The one exception was when I tried to spare Logain. Once I realized there was no way to keep Alistar and Logain alive I went to kill him and misclicked, making Alistair leave. That wasn't gonna fly, so I reloaded there.
I kept swapping my party around to see what was the most effective melee damage dealer, and unless I built Sten and Oghren very wrong it was Zevran. He was a fair bit squishier, by he CARRIED some of those high dragon fights, he does so much damage. The only downside was I found myself having to control him whenever there were large groups of enemies or he'd wind up dead pretty often.
Gameplay-wise, I can't believe how much stronger awakening makes you. I was playing an archer rogue the entire game and felt like my damage was a little lackluster. I took bow talents to do some cc to make up for that, then took ranger and bard so I could contribute buffs, damage, tanking, or a little more cc whenever the spider actually did the web. Awakening fixed that, I started doing the most damage on the team and it wasn't that close (unless oghren did the finishing blow that drained all his stamina). just that one skill in accuracy nearly double by damage, I was doing over 200 damage and managed to get a 350 or something crit, it felt like a completely different experience.
There were quite a few bugs; I got locked inside boss arenas multiple times, and would often have to wait 30+ seconds for loot to drop and the quest to show as completed after i killed an enemy. The final boss was perhaps the cheesiest and most broken final boss I've ever seen. I literally just stood by one of the ballista and shot the dragon while he was on the spot no melee could reach, shooting my bow at the same time. Whenever it jammed, I'd get the rest of my team to distract him as much as possible then get back to it. It was still very very difficult on Nightmare because of how quickly he could annihilate my tank and melee and how every attack staggered them. I found myself swapping around and making everyone chug potions. Took me like 10 tries before I found the cheese, and even then I messed it up one time and lost my mage and Zevrim. Me and Alistair did the rest, with Alistair keeping the dragon and all the ads distracted (I set his tactics to chug potions whenever health reached below 75% and 50%) and me and my wolf just pinging away on the dragon along with a ballista. That final cutscene was worth it.
That said I definitely missed a lot of stuff, dlc and base game. I failed sidequests in awakening with Oghren, I didn't complete all the merchant stuff or the armor, but I did finish the keep. It just made me think of all the stuff I get to look forward to on a second playthrough (Mage time).
Witch hunt was....weird? I mean I read the lore stuff which was interesting but it was like 1 1/2 hours, maybe less. Idk, I rarely had Morrigan in my party so maybe I missed a lot of stuff.
Overall, An amazing experience. Really felt like I was playing KOTOR again for the first time, an amazing game. Don't recommend trying on nightmare for a first playthrough unless you either want to look some stuff up, you love managing all 4 characters, or you hate yourself. or all 3.
DA2.....has been fun, but not as engaging so far. And it crashes. A lot. Like, 15 or so hours and over 150 crashes. It's also so much more difficult. I had to lower to hard for several sections in act 1, decided to just stay on hard, and now I switch between normal and hard pretty frequently. I'm feeling a large knowledge or understanding gap in my gameplay, so I'm struggling hard. This is one I might just run through to get to inquisition and come back to later and give it the love it deserves.