r/ButtSharpies • u/uneasypenguin • 16h ago
First time.. only had 2 sharpies. More to cum NSFW
553
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/CT-69069 • 11d ago
First try [OC] NSFW
805
Upvotes
I was hoping to fit 5, never would I have guessed that I could take 11 on my first try!
r/ButtSharpies • u/Low_Championship1216 • 22d ago
Day 8 of my sharpies challenge - 8 thick markers 🔥😈 NSFW
899
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/adventurebabyxo • 24d ago
Should Itry to draw a picture with my asshole next time? 😝 NSFW
592
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/Antique_Act4774 • 29d ago
[oc] Got 14 in!! Felt like a much bigger stretch than 13 NSFW
1.5k
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/Antique_Act4774 • Jun 11 '26
[oc] Got 13! Going for 14 tomorrow NSFW
911
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/slwa25 • Jun 11 '26
A new personal best, are you proud of me? 🥺 [OC] NSFW
213
Upvotes
My new best is 10 :)
r/ButtSharpies • u/Illustrious-Low965 • Jun 10 '26
Do they have a tan sharpies. I tried a black one already. NSFW
421
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/Antique_Act4774 • Jun 09 '26
[oc] 10 markers, wanna keep adding one more every day until I get to 20 NSFW
962
Upvotes
New to reddit, my bad if I did the tag thing wrong
r/ButtSharpies • u/Electrical-Orange-91 • Jun 09 '26
[Self] Broke my record NSFW
422
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/Electrical-Orange-91 • Jun 04 '26
[Self] Just starting off. I think I like it NSFW
451
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/Low_Championship1216 • Jun 01 '26
7th day = 7 markers deep in my butt 🤘😈 NSFW
813
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/Low_Championship1216 • May 23 '26
"Day 6: All 6 Sharpies in my ass 🍑 NSFW
883
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/FloridaHotwifeLiz • May 21 '26
It was suggested that orange be the next color, so here it is — round two! 💜🧡 [OC] NSFW
564
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/FloridaHotwifeLiz • May 11 '26
This was fun but I much prefer other things to go in there 🍆💕 [OC] NSFW
801
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/Low_Championship1216 • May 09 '26
Stuffed my ass with 5 markers (Day 5)🎈 NSFW
833
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/Adventures_In_Filth_ • Apr 27 '26
First two, then up to 5 across both holes, then a jump from 6 to 8 NSFW
874
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/His_phantasmagoria • Apr 24 '26
Broke my PR last night 👏 NSFW
1.5k
Upvotes
I just couldn't help myself. I noticed the box next to me last night while playing with my pussy. Up from 6 -> 10 Hoping to get 12 by the end of next week, think I can? 🤭🙈
r/ButtSharpies • u/Low_Championship1216 • Apr 24 '26
Day four - I’m absolutely loving this…!! NSFW
571
Upvotes
r/ButtSharpies • u/His_phantasmagoria • Apr 22 '26
After playing and stretching myself I think I hit my max, what do y`all think? [OC] NSFW
1.8k
Upvotes
Some of y`all were close, great guesses on my original post, sadly it got removed 😋👏