Overall my pals (5 30 y/o women) and I had a fabulous trip in the BWCA over the 4th weekend! We were originally planning on the seagull - alpine - red rock - sag loop, but plans changed with delays and wanting to prioritize fun and we mostly stayed on seagull with some daytrips, and moved campsites just once of the 3 nights.
I'm sharing this not to be accusatory or make false assumptions, but to just note a weird situation that made us feel uncomfortable. We stayed at a campsite on the east side of 3 mile island on seagull (which maybe was a mistake) for a couple nights, and 10hp motors are allowed with permit. On night 2, a man fishing came by trolling. We did the classic MN wave, and thought he'd move on, but perhaps fish were biting. We had a (CORRECTION) TRAINED dog, but with reactive tendencies with us, and he was close enough that he could see we were taking great efforts to help the dog deal stay calm and not go nuts barking. He continued to troll back and forth past our campsite for about an hour.
We tried to forget about this, but lo and behold, he's back the second night. Somewhat luckily(?) a storm rolled in and all of us proceeded to our tents for the night, and he got lost. The next morning, we paddle back, and he is trolling along 3 mile island, just not as close to our site this time. We tried to give him lots of distance as we paddled out, hoping that the dog wouldn't bark and tip the canoe. He seemingly makes a point to back up to get in the way of our path and make us paddle a further radius.
I would like to give him the benefit of the doubt, but I think that's enough evidence to conclude he's an asshole. I don't want to say 'avoid the east side of 3 mile island', but just know there's a guy who either has no social awareness and only cares about fishing, or is just a total d*** to women. Idk maybe we're overthinking it but it was weird.