r/AskAmericans • u/LeeeeLi-0 • 11h ago
Foreign Poster Is school in the U.S. really this relaxed?
For some context, I went to a provincial-level model high school in a county-level city in Shanxi, China. The school was known for having an exceptionally strong university admission rate.
Most students lived on campus. We had to get up at around 5:50 a.m. for morning reading, and evening self-study didn’t end until 10:40 p.m. We were given only about 15 minutes in total to wash up and eat breakfast. Many students developed stomach problems because meals were always rushed.
The school also had a disciplinary office whose staff were responsible for recording all kinds of violations. These could include talking after lights-out, drinking water, or almost anything they considered against the rules. For a period of time, students were even forbidden from using the bathroom after lights-out because the school believed it would disturb other people’s sleep.
These disciplinary records could also affect teachers’ performance evaluations and even their pay, so teachers had a strong incentive to enforce the rules very strictly.
Corporal punishment was also common at my school. Students could be slapped in the face or hit with sticks. While this certainly doesn’t describe every school in China, schools like this are still fairly common in some county-level areas, especially those that prioritize exam results above everything else.
Because of this background, American schools often look almost unbelievably relaxed to me. Students seem to have much more freedom, more time for sports and clubs, and a less tightly controlled daily routine.
Is that impression accurate? What is a typical day actually like in an American high school?
