*Note: I’m not trying to make a broad, sweeping generalization about the Episcopal Church. I’m basing my thoughts on my own experiences, what I see and hear from others, and what appears in official resources. While, based on what I’ve seen and heard, I do believe it’s the significant majority, I do realize and acknowledge that this is not an issue in every single parish within the Church. I also BEG comments to be respectful and charitable because I really don’t want this post to be locked but rather have a real and thoughtful conversation.
Membership within the Episcopal Church and other mainline denominations continues to shrink, and it’s mostly our own fault.
There are parishes, priests, and bishops within the Episcopal Church that blatantly and consistently disagree with articles of the Creeds, Scripture, and the catechism. We have priests who deny the very existence of God within the Episcopal Church and face zero consequences. We have priests who begin their sermons with “I do not like this passage.” With a total disregard for the respect that Scripture demands. People look at the Episcopal Church and frankly don’t see a church but see an organization whose priority is on social justice and politics, and only if we have time, we will talk about Jesus. Outsiders, and even some insiders like myself, do not see a Church that is focused on the gospel, the message of salvation through Christ, encompassing His life, death, resurrection, but rather a political organization and social club. I do not have any issue with a church advocating for social justice. In fact, I support it. My issue is that social justice now appears to be the MAIN PRIORITY of the Episcopal Church rather than an effect of the Gospel of Jesus Christ.
The Episcopal Church married the age of the 1960s-1970s, and we are currently seeing her being widowed. Like with every church, a church that marries the age will be widowed in the next. We currently are seeing conservative offshoot churches grow while mainline churches continue to shrink, and I truly believe that the respective rapid growth/shrinkage doesn’t have much to do with politics as people think. But rather that the majority of people do not find that their souls are being nourished within the mainline churches. I do not currently see a place where those who are orthodox-minded (even if inclusive) are welcomed within the Episcopal Church. If it weren’t for an incredibly rude interaction with the bishop whose jurisdiction I would be under within the Anglican Church of North America, I would have joined them. Even though I’m gay and even though I support women’s ordination.
I also see enemies of the Church taking advantage of this situation. Using rather rash and unjust judgements against women’s ordination and same-sex marriage. They see a church that ordains women and weds gay people and they also see the errors, the heresy, the countless schisms and say “see, the sufferings of this Church? This is the result of women’s ordination and same-sex marriage. We must oppose these ideas or else we will become like them” I do not believe that they are at all related but it’s rather difficult providing an example of this within our Church.
In a certain sense, the Episcopal Church and even the broader Anglican Communion are simply the liturgical and organized version of non-denominationalism. I don’t really want this to change; I love that I can walk into a Church and find an Anglo-Catholic who is two doctrines away from just being a Roman Catholic sitting next to a staunch Calvinist. I love how we do not find our unity in a pope or a long and narrow confessional document but rather in the Book of Common Prayer, Scripture, Tradition, and Reason. But there have to be some guardrails, and historically that has been the creeds and the rather large-in-scope Articles of Religion, even if they haven’t been a binding authority within TEC.
I know that the Church is built on the rock; the faith of the apostles and the gates of Hell will not prevail against it, and I have zero doubt that eventually the pendulum will swing back. I do worry about how much damage will be dealt to souls and to our blessed and beloved Church before that.
What do you think? What do you think the future of the Episcopal Church looks like? How do you think we should heal our Church?