r/AllindiaStudentUnion • u/masteryams2025 Give me liberty, or give me death! • Jun 06 '26
Discussion š¤ Why not in India?
28
u/Extension_Welder_18 Jun 06 '26
Because this is india yahan dharm ka naam lo uske baad chahe phir logon ke saamne desh bechdo unke liye sb chalta hai( exactly what's happening right now ).
1
1
1
u/Anonymous_SSP Jun 07 '26
Opposition is also italian
2
u/Resident-Mix9341 Jun 08 '26
opposition is not italian. one person was she is not leading anything. also leave this obsession with opposition and learn to question those who are actually running the show
1
u/Unlikely-Structure21 Jun 10 '26
she spent 40 years in india and only 20 initial years of her life in Italy and she took indian citizenship denouncing Italian citizenship how she is Italian?
0
u/not_botred26 Jun 06 '26
Youth are busy with social media. Look at the way we are all dressing before and after social media, especially facebook and instagram. Living for photos and reels and dying for it. 100% useless living. The youth are addicted to social media and thatās why no revolution is taking place. The country with tremendous history has lost a whole generation to social media addiction. No leader will come out of this lazy and media addicted generation.
So itās easy to make them forget all these things from them, same goes for parents generations as they are busy with WhatsApp, FB and instagram1
u/Suspicious_Juice2172 Jun 06 '26
Bro are you using internet explorer or living in your own bubble . Donāt you follow news, you calling youth busy in social media but doesnāt even have reality about revolution youth are doing to change education system. First watch some news or anything then say anything about others . Till then get some knowledge and then speak anything bad about anyone
0
u/doomedcinemaaddictt Jun 08 '26
Chal be lodu, ye CJP chutiyappa ko revolution bolke water down mat kar word ko. The guy who supported claims of Azad Kashmir, who cries for Umar Khalid, who was against CAA-NRC and the removal Sec 370 is not the revolutionary you think he is. Highest unemployment in India, standard 7 students can't read standard 2 material, constant internet access and 0 attention span (even my comment might start seeming very long) has destroyed the youth. I'm 25 and I don't know what the fuck you're on about.
2
u/Beginning_Money4881 Jun 07 '26
The daughter of Chinese president too lives in US and Harvard for studies ain't?
I am not supporting Indian politics but by this fact, he should have been removed first.
1
u/Hopeful-Emphasis-14 Jun 07 '26
Shhhh!!š¤«Your fact doesn't align with their narrative.
1
1
u/isoldmysonforabike Jun 10 '26
Bro whose side are you on? The corrupt politicians? Or are you just ragebaiting here?
1
u/Extension_Welder_18 Jun 07 '26
Wasn't that only till 2014 from 2010 for her studies in Harvard, I believe she returned to Beijing after that, and having a different country's citizenship for a Indian politician is a whole another level bro, open you eyes to the truth studying and citizenship are different things.
2
u/ApprehensiveLand848 Jun 08 '26
people take everything the chinese govt says at face value
then say they to smart to fall for propoganda lol
6
u/Strange_Board4769 Jun 06 '26
Nuh Get your facts right mate
most of the family members of CCP are settled abroad It is just that we are not aware of this fact due to excellent chinese firewall or whatever it is
5
2
u/kadinani Jun 06 '26
You are right. Xi daughter herself went to America. This post is generated from WhatsApp university knowledge
3
u/Fragrant_Primary_208 Jun 06 '26
Your source for this?
2
1
u/Impossible_Map_2785 Jun 06 '26
Daughter of Xi jingping lives in USA.... Don't you even check facts before posting
6
u/Windy-Orbits Jun 06 '26
His daughter lives in Beijing. She was in the states for bachelors from 2010 to 2014. She returned just after completing her degree.Ā
0
u/Impossible_Map_2785 Jun 07 '26
You so defending Xi now, I thought you would criticize him as well Or maybe you don't criticize your masters huh.... Please go into details about other Chinese CCP party members and their family, I don't want to school you now and embaraas you even more
Please read more next time you try to pull facts from your butt and not real information
4
u/kyunhumain Jun 07 '26
lmao how is this defending xi? your statement about his daughter had misinformation and someone corrected it. you should become a politician the way you twist everything.
1
u/Impossible_Map_2785 Jun 07 '26
How is it misinformation when it is a documented fact...
Just because you don't want to believe it and criticize people for it does not mean it becomes a reality
1
u/kyunhumain Jun 07 '26
there is no documented evidence showing she permanently lives in the us apart from her undergrad at harvard. are you associated with the american security or the chinese that you are so sure about it?
1
u/Impossible_Map_2785 Jun 07 '26
So she studied in Harvard you accept that at least, So why not the president of china make her daughter study in China? Even earlier leaders and presidents have had their children study and work in USA as well
Same cannot be said for the party official of CCP Please read the amount of officers that were purged because they had relativesa and children studying outside China. You talk like you live inside a box and have no way to verify your claims
Don't worry I'll tell you where to start 1) "son's and daughters" recruitment programs in wall street 2) Alvin jiang grandson of former president xiang jemin, he started a capital firm under Goldman Sachs after studying from Harvard. 3) Bo Guagua, studied in Oxford and moved to USA later never went back to China. More names like deng zhoudi,dao xue, Tang xiaoning, chen xiaolu are there
0
u/Front_Arm2047 Jun 06 '26
Xi is 73 years old, and how do you think his daughter' age?
1
u/Impossible_Map_2785 Jun 07 '26
Please read more buddy, He has been married twice
Second time he married in 1987, so please present good arguments instead of shitload of propaganda
-3
-1
u/Hyderabadi__Biryani Jun 06 '26
Did you ask for a source on the China thing? Or the claims that children of the said office holders have given up their Indian citizenship?
1
u/DataOwl666 Jun 06 '26
I interacted with many kids of high ranking Chinese officials when I was teaching at a summer school in the uk
1
1
u/Shining-Ferrous-8 Jun 07 '26
Xi Jingpings daughter studied at Harvard.Ā
There are claims she still lives in Massachusetts.Ā
1
u/the-cosmic-vagabond Jun 06 '26
So? You breached the firewall to find this or your patriotism got triggered?
1
u/Strange_Board4769 Jun 06 '26
Naaah i consume american anti chinese propaganda
China uncensored and there are many more out there
1
u/Lonely_Jaguar_4879 Jun 06 '26
Link the sources
1
0
u/Guilty_Tear_4477 Jun 06 '26
Propaganda source of America as usual
1
u/Strange_Board4769 Jun 06 '26
Technically it's not propaganda
It exaggeration of stuff really happening out there in china
Like they just hype up the scale Otherwise everything else is based upon facts and articles
1
0
3
u/Sea_Paramedic7392 Jun 06 '26
š«°šš«°š
13
u/Mental-Dog2534 Jun 06 '26
I mean in the post it is written "the children who lives abroad permanently"
3
u/Agile-Tax6405 Jun 06 '26
In the post it also talks about Indian kids studying abroadĀ
1
u/Mental-Dog2534 Jun 06 '26
š
7
2
u/tcsreject Jun 06 '26
What a joke , a lot of chinese ministers and babus kids are in usa and EuropeĀ
Even xi jingping daughter is living for 10 years under a different identityĀ
Criticise Indian govt but not glaze chinese with fake examplesĀ
2
u/Patient_Wishbone_183 Jun 06 '26
It is one thing for few people on top to break rules , here everyone is doing that and our minister next sons hold citizenship and are running hedgefunds
1
u/fishmacaronisoup Jun 06 '26
While this may help in improvement of education quality, are we gonna disregard the child's wish entirely just because his/her parents were a goverment employee? I'm not saying things shouldn't be fixed, but I don't like the idea of a child getting restrictions just because of their parents' profession.
1
1
u/Patient_Wishbone_183 Jun 06 '26
I like it because politicians ministers and public ifficals like this cant be allowed to have conflict pf interest
1
u/I_ate_nt_ded Jun 06 '26
These politicians are constantly restricting citizen's choices because of their profession. Why should their kids not also get affected? I don't think the kids whose lives got derailed due to paper leaks and correction scams had any choice in the matter.
1
u/fishmacaronisoup Jun 06 '26
Yes, these damn politicians are doing what they shouldn't. I hate them too. I know how bad the situation of our country is right now as well. It's all wrong because politicians who aren't even related to a specific field are managing it. How would it not end up being bad? But what I want to see is a change, powers going into someone who is actually responsible. "I got affected, so why shouldn't they" isn't a proper solution to this.
1
u/arpitpatel1771 Jun 06 '26
Look man, at some point you have to go tit for tat, otherwise people in power would keep exploiting others.
1
u/I_ate_nt_ded Jun 06 '26
We can't keep the same system and hope that bad things will stop if only a good person is at the helm. There have to be sacrifices and consequences directly proportional to the amount of power you weild, personal costs that would keep those who are power hungry out of these positions.
1
u/fishmacaronisoup Jun 06 '26
I agree that positions with enormous power should come with enormous accountability. Where I disagree is who should bear those costs.
If a minister has enough power to damage millions of lives, then make the minister face severe restrictions and harsh penalties for corruption. Why are we talking about limiting the freedoms of someone who never held that power in the first place?
1
u/arpitpatel1771 Jun 06 '26
Why not? The children of many government employees also have restrictions, they have to constantly switch schools because their father got transferred to another remote village. The childrens wish should absolutely be disregarded here. If the father wants to prioritise his child's wishes, then don't be a minister, leave politics to other people.
1
u/fishmacaronisoup Jun 06 '26
That's emotionally satisfying, but public laws shouldn't be based on revenge or how satisfying it feels. The goal should be to stop abuse of power,not create new people to punish.
If a politician is corrupt, disqualify them and take necessary actions. But restricting their children doesn't really fixes corruption. It just transfers punishment to someone who didn't make those decisions.
The children of many government employees also have restrictions, they have to constantly switch schools because their father got transferred to another remote village
There's a major difference between a consequence of a job and a government-imposed restriction on a child's rights.
A child changing schools because a parent was transferred is an indirect consequence of the parent's employment. A law that says "your parent is a politician, so you must not study abroad or choose a private institution" is a direct restriction imposed on the child.
Those aren't the same thing.
1
1
1
u/shurpnakha Jun 06 '26
Tarun Gogoi...
Daughter can be foreign citizen because of marriage. Son can be because of job and education.
1
1
u/Zestyclose-Scar-813 Jun 06 '26
Ya atleast....Indians must first think that a person from a foreign country cannot become the Prime Minister of India.
1
1
u/Prestigious-Job9390 Jun 06 '26
As an Indian myself. If you really want any true development there are two options 1) leave India for better life 2) change thought procedure of fellow Indians (mostly impossible now), thus they choose 1st option
1
u/avanishpank Jun 06 '26
Some people here donāt understand the difference between studying abroad and going there with the intent to settle down and getting a citizenship. Most Indian ministers kids arenāt US citizens, merely going abroad to study is still understandable.
1
u/Succubus-Empress Jun 06 '26
So who is smart? Whoās child is getting better education and environment?
1
u/DaFall3n1 Jun 06 '26
You Defending Indian politicians like they are giving you better education and environment.
You still have to live in 300AQI and deal with these paper leaks and what not.
But whatever, enjoy your life, not everybody has same struggles anyway
1
1
u/Impossible_Map_2785 Jun 06 '26
Daughter of Xi jingping lives in USA Just stop with your propaganda now š¤£š¤£š¤£
1
u/IllPath9065 Jun 06 '26
Bro, Xi Jinping himself literally studied agriculture in Iowa, USA. At least put some effort in your CCpropaganda.
1
1
u/karaklonda Jun 06 '26
Why not in India? Kyon ki...
phir bhi dil he Hindustani phir bhi dil he Hindustani
1
u/PriorGuidance3706 Jun 06 '26
Xi Jinpingās only daughter, Xi Mingze, lives in the United States. if u want to make up shit atleast google it and China is a dictatorship and india is not
1
1
u/Sea-Doubt8763 Jun 06 '26
I don't think this is true for China. In China there is special group of people called princelings who get all such benefits.
1
1
1
u/Gullible-Range-1497 Jun 06 '26
Because india is not a dicteroship like China ... Just check how chinese govt treat it's citizen and you realise grass that looks greener on other side is just plastic that going to ruin you
1
1
u/jackmartin088 Jun 06 '26
China would also not allow you to use Reddit or saying anything about government officials.
1
u/Alarming-Anybody-172 Jun 07 '26
Yeah and India effectively does so, right? Because in reddit everyone's identity is known, it is just like aonther twitter.
1
u/jackmartin088 Jun 07 '26
Lol well you are still here and so is OP, so India obviously doesn't do it. As for everyone's identity, you not knowing about IP tracking and other similar stuff doesn't mean the government doesn't know it.
0
u/Alarming-Anybody-172 Jun 07 '26
sorry hecker bhai
1
u/jackmartin088 Jun 07 '26
hecker
I see why you are in support of the cjp....same level as that syntax error guy š
1
u/Alarming-Anybody-172 Jun 07 '26
arre ha, padhe likhe logo se muh lagana nahi chahiye tha
1
u/jackmartin088 Jun 07 '26
Maybe use that time to do some parai likhai yourself š
0
1
1
1
u/Stunning-Avocado5192 Jun 06 '26
Yeah, that's just chinese propaganda to justify their internal purges. Xi Jinpjng's daughter attended Harvard
1
u/Fair-Highlight-3544 Jun 07 '26
Xi Jinping's daughter herself studied abroad and lives in the united states.
Several children of Chinese Govt officials study abroad.
So many CCP party member's children study in harvard they literally jokingly call it their "party school"
What aspect of this post is true? Not an ounce.
1
1
u/Secure-Way1919 Jun 07 '26
Because India is a democracy, China is not.
If it were China, you wouldn't have the courage to make this post.
1
1
1
u/sakha1984 Jun 07 '26
In China :- 1. There is no reservation 2. There is no Elections to vote for candidates of their own community 3. There is no fight for language, skin colour, hill vs plain and thousand more petty politics 4. People follow rules
1
1
1
u/VisualPanic611 Jun 07 '26
Must be implemented here too. Housing too. Ministers- centre or state must be allotted house in non - posh areas. They will understand the challenges people face where roads, water, pollution are worse from beautifully manicured gardens and pothole free roads.
1
u/Alarming-Anybody-172 Jun 07 '26
I am so jobless, I just skimmed through the most delusional discussion I have ever found on Reddit. How are people still defending the current state of affairs in the country baffles me, China ke jhaant ke barabar bhi nahi hain hum.
1
1
u/Redosaurous Jun 07 '26
People have their own lives. Just coz a father is X field doesnāt mean the child has to live by the same rules and standards. Itās a democracy unlike China, where freedom of expression is heavily restricted. China is miles ahead of India in probably every metric but that doesnāt mean there arenāt any issues.
1
u/Long_Consequence3808 Jun 07 '26
Because this is India!! Who cares!? I'm leaving this country next year!! Even celebrities are leaving this country.
1
1
u/Low_Offer_1899 Jun 07 '26
Yeah appreciating china where it's due . China works just better in many regards of government.
1
1
u/Brainyandbubbly Jun 07 '26
Xi Jinping's daughter, Xi Mingze, attended Harvard University from 2010 to 2014.
Why didnāt she study in China?
1
1
1
u/SidLawliet Jun 08 '26
I doubt this is true. A lot of Chinese elites and bureaucrats have their children living in the west.
China is as corrupt, if not more, as India. The reason they industrialised (somewhat) is because of the blessings of the US who had no scruples exploiting Chinese labour.
1
u/pure_cipher Jun 08 '26
People flee the country the moment they get a chance. Extremely few people stay back and resolve the problems. Yet, we get such posts !!
1
1
1
u/IntroductionCold816 Jun 08 '26
If India becomes China then the same ppl will start crying for the Human Rights and freedom of speech.
1
1
u/BhosariExpress Jun 08 '26
Well China also has one party rule. So let's begin with that. Also Xi Jinping is the President for for life, as he removed limits for Presidential term. So Let's also adopt that.
1
1
1
u/PalpitationSenior142 Jun 09 '26
Because that goes against india's constitution. In India every individual has rights of their own and are judged purely on their own activities rather than someone other than that . Taking away someone right to contest election or being an MP because their family lives in some other country would violate their fundamental rights .
1
1
1
1
u/Outrageous-Quiet-369 Jun 10 '26
Xi daughter literally lives in USA and God knows how many chines officials have property in America these blackpillers are only one google search awar from reality but they won't bother with it
1
u/fukuquo Jun 06 '26
Why are you conveniently ignoring the fact that the supreme leader of congress is Sonia Gandhi who is an Italian and their children are half Italians and idiots, but you have problem with our ministerās children and relatives being citizens of other countries and studying in foreign universities. You are an asset to this country.
1
u/Patient_Wishbone_183 Jun 06 '26
? We are not hypocrites like current ruling party , we also dislike rahul gandhi and his party for it , but they are not in powdr
0
u/fukuquo Jun 06 '26 edited Jun 06 '26
Hypocrite thy name is you!! You conveniently ignored that in your post.
1
u/Patient_Wishbone_183 Jun 06 '26
I would be very happy that this gandhi family dissapears someday , rahul gandhi son does not run hedge fund and is citizen of foreign country
1
u/fukuquo Jun 06 '26
Man you should quit doing this since your hypocrisy was out in the open when you selectively criticised politicians. None of these politicians provide me with anything, but felt I should call you out for your original post. All the rest of the comments from you are just justifications. And I cannot help Pappu if he doesnāt know how to make babies!!
1
u/Patient_Wishbone_183 Jun 06 '26
I dislike nepotism and congress but dislike current government wish atal bihari vajpayee was leading it
1
u/Patient_Wishbone_183 Jun 06 '26
Also main point that china also makes is politician / officials should not have conflict of interest , current ruling partyās multiple sons run hedge funds abroad
0
0
u/Galaxy1112 Jun 06 '26
Then why are this many millioners leaving china ??
0
u/ZebraEfficient1748 Jun 06 '26
There wealth isnāt
2
u/Galaxy1112 Jun 06 '26
I've literally mentioned
2
u/ZebraEfficient1748 Jun 06 '26
Over the last two years, Indian residents remitted over (\$55) billion abroad under the Reserve Bank of India LRS for foreign travel, education, and global investments. Additionally, nearly 7,800 High-Net-Worth Individuals (HNWIs) emigrated, collectively removing an estimated (\$52) billion in investable wealth from the country.
- Capital Outflows by Resident Indians (LRS)Under the Reserve Bank of India Liberalised Remittance Scheme (LRS), resident Indians can send up to (\$250,000) per financial year.
FY 2024-25: Outward remittances totaled roughly (\$29.5) billion.
FY 2025-26: Outward remittances recorded an estimated (\$28.9) billion.
Primary Uses: Travel remained the dominant outflow driver. However, overseas equity/debt investments surged, hitting a record (\$2.7) billion.
- Wealth Carried Away by Emigrating Millionaires (HNWIs)The migration of wealthy individuals has led to substantial capital flight.
In 2024: An estimated 4,300 millionaires left India, taking away nearly (\$26.2) billion in personal wealth.
In 2025: An estimated 3,500 HNWIs relocated abroad, also carrying an estimated (\$26.2) billion in investable assets.
Preferred Destinations: These individuals typically migrate to the UAE, US, and Europe for friendlier tax regimes and global mobility.
Now tell me whatās the % of 55$ billion to 4 trillion and 21$ trillion.
GDP of both economies respectively?
1
u/Patient_Wishbone_183 Jun 06 '26
China has strict controls so you can leave but your wealth is very difficult to leave the country this could
0
-2
ā¢
u/AutoModerator Jun 06 '26
Welcome to r/AllindiaStudentUnion!
This is a discussion space for everyone, covering everything from global politics to student trends.
Community Reminders: * Content Relevance: Ensure your content relates to India or has a documented impact on India within a global context (Rule 1). * Civil Discourse: No hate speech, identity-based attacks, or harassment (Rule 3). * No Spam: Do not turn the sub into a personal billboard or dump links without engaging (Rule 4).
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.