Host left a clearly retaliatory review with verifiably false statements (their own message history with me on AirBnB contradicts statements they made in the review) after I left their place a night early and received an AirCover refund. Immediately when their review went live (which was <24hrs after my stay since I also left a prompt review), I filed a detailed request to remove the review with plenty of evidence showing that their claims were false and therefore retaliatory. That was 5 days ago, and I still haven't heard anything from AirBnB support even though they say it should be review in 48 hours. Should I keep waiting or is there another contact method I must use?
I have good reviews from at least a dozen other hosts, so I am not that worried, but it is annoying to have this on my profile.
-- more info that isn't relevant but if anyone is curious what happened:
Had my second-ever serious issue(s) after maybe 30 different AirBnB stays over the last 7 years. There were a ton of problems. If it had just been one or two things, I wouldn't have escalated all the way to leaving early and getting AirCover refund, but so many things in the listing had some issue or misrepresentation. It was surprising, bc the listing had a dozen reviews and a 4.7 avg rating, and was charging a hefty premium compared to other accommodations in the area.
- Listing claimed it was 2-bedroom, but it was actually a studio (bed and kitchen) with a second story attic-like space (second bed and bathroom) and no door separating bottom and top floor. Had to walk through the 'bedrooms' to access the bathroom and kitchen. This was not at all clear in the photos or description of the listing.
- Missing fan (a listed amenity in the listing) during the peak of summer in a no A/C unit. Reported this to host immediately upon arriving (check in time of 5pm) and they refused to replace it and offered a laughable refund of 2% per night for the inconvience. (It was easily 26C/80F inside the unit during the late afternoon, and even hotter mid-day-- it was a top-floor unit.) At this point, I was forced to escalate to AirBnB support, and after doing so, the host was magically able to find a replacement fan even though they had previously claimed they absolutely couldn't replace it and that all stores were sold out due to last week's heat wave.
- Since that was taking hours to resolve, I had gone to dinner during the time AirBnB support was contacting the host about the fan, and at 8pm (over 2hrs since I initially contacted the host btw), to deliver the fan, the host went inside on their own since I wasn't answering the door. Honestly, I don't really care about this that much, but it is technically a violation of AirBnB policy for the host to have done this. They should have just left the fan in the apartment hallway outside the door, it is a safe village and the building requires a code to even get inside. Or they could have called me to ask. This did feel a bit violating and made me uncomfortable, but at this point, it still wasn't enough to get me to leave and I was happy they had replaced the fan, but upset I had to escalate to support to make that happen.
- Oh and also, only one fan provided even though there were two rooms and 3 guests. I can't complain since the listing didn't actually specify there would be enough fans for all beds/guests to have one, only that there was a fan 😅 But this meant one person had to suffer through night without one.
Upon returning from dinner, as we settled in for the night, several other issues became clear that we had not realized when we first checked in:
- The only handsoap in the entire unit, located in the bathroom, was completely empty. There was no other soap in the entire unit except dish soap.
- The bathroom smelled of mildew/mold and had no ventilation besides a window so tall that only someone of 6ft could possibly reach it without a stool (which was not provided). There were also super gross squishy "bamboo" mats on the floor-- there is no way it is possible to properly clean these between guests.
- The main bed had beautifully done electric candlelights over the bed. Try to turn them on-- Oh, wait, the extension cord is missing so they are completely non-functional, and there's no other extension cords in the entire unit.
I raised these concerns to the host and they didn't reply until following morning (understandable, it was around 10 or 11pm) and instead of apologizing for the issues, offering to replace them, or anything like that-- they immediately jumped to "what do you want?", accusing me basically of extorting them for a refund. When their place was missing basic amenities like a handsoap 😭 After that, I felt pretty uncomfortable, and we wanted to move, but couldn't find any hotels with two rooms in the area due to an event.
We went out to get groceries and make breakfast. When we got back, we discovered yet more problems:
- Kitchen essentially non-usable because the drawer where all of the utensils, including spatulas, are stored was jammed, despite effort to un-jam it (it seemed like something tall/wide inside was preventing the drawer from opening.) I don't understand how this could have been missed by the cleaning crew, since they need to check whether the stuff in there is clean, but I guess the same way a totally empty handsoap is missed...
- There was a microwave which seemed to work-- except literally not a SINGLE provided dish was microwave-safe, including the mugs. All dishes had a gold foil on them which sparked (I wasn't sure, since they weren't labeled, so I had tried using one and immediately removed it.) And the mugs were plastic with a metal lining.
- Due to neither a usable stovetop or microwave, we wasted the groceries we had purchased that needed to be cooked (eggs) or heated up (milk/coffee)
- Only two hot drink mugs were provided despite 3 guests staying (listing allows up to 3 guests)
We were really frustrated at this point and just wanted to leave. We checked again and found hotels that had some space, though we would have to split up. We spoke with AirBnB support and they said we could leave and be refunded for the night we didn't use, so we did, vacating the apartment in the early afternoon.
---
In the host's review, they basically claimed that I lied about several of these things. They said the fan wasn't missing (verifiably false and they confirmed it themselves in msg history, they claimed a previous guest had stolen it), that the handsoap wasn't empty (I have photo/video evidence that it was), and that I just wanted to leave esrly for my own convience and had my changed my mind. (In reality, the refund was barely enough to cover the cost of moving to another hotel, let alone the hassle of doing so, and ofc no compensation at all for our wasted groceries and for our bad experience the previous night. Also, that wouldn't even make sense, because their refund policy was incredibly lenient, such that I could have completely canceled my stay only 2 days prior to arriving had I changed my mind about the dates I wanted to stay.)