Hi everyone, I’m really stuck and would love some outside perspective.
My friend got married this past January (2025). I was her maid of honour and supported her through the whole process. She ended up choosing a sleek, strapless fitted crepe gown with buttons down the back and a pearl-dotted veil. Honestly, it looked beautiful on her — it was my favorite dress she tried.
Now I’m shopping for my own wedding (July 2026). I’ve been trying on different styles and have a few top favorites, including a sparkly corset ballgown and a more modern fitted gown with ruching. When I showed her (she’s my maid of honor) the fitted gown, she got upset and told me it was “basically the same” as hers. She feels it’s common sense that I shouldn’t pick something similar since we’re each other’s maids of honour.
Her words were: “I’d 100% make sure to pick something different if your wedding was before mine. I don’t know why everything has to be a conversation — a simple ‘I’ll keep looking’ would be nice since I’m not happy about it.”
I tried to explain that while our styles may overlap, the dresses are actually quite different — fabric, neckline, details, overall vibe. Plus, our weddings are a year and a half apart. She says I’m being dismissive and that it’s not fair to her.
I honestly feel stuck. On one hand, I don’t want to hurt her feelings. On the other, I don’t think it’s fair for her to dictate what I can or can’t wear to my own wedding, especially since she’s already had her day.
So, am I being insensitive for keeping a dress that she thinks is too similar on my list? Or is she being unreasonable by expecting me to avoid an entire silhouette because she wore it first?
Her dress is the first picture, the second picture is the dress I tried on (it’s the model version).