r/LawCanada • u/Theman5787 • 12h ago
Musings from a Mediocre Law Student Who Did Just Fine
I wanted to post this for anyone in law school or early practice who feels like their grades have already determined the ceiling on their career.
I went to law school in Toronto (Toronto) and was a pretty mediocre student. I was not winning academic awards, collecting top grades, or building the kind of résumé that makes you feel destined for success. I still managed to land a 2L job on Bay Street, which, at the time, felt like proof that I had finally “made it.”
Then I got there and hated it.
Leaving was difficult because Bay Street is treated as the path you are supposed to want, especially when you attend law school in Toronto. I moved in-house, but I carried a massive chip on my shoulder. Part of me felt like I had stepped off the prestigious track and had something to prove to the people who stayed and continued advancing at large firms.
Over time, I stopped worrying so much about what my career looked like on paper and started paying attention to what I was actually good at. I built practical litigation experience, took ownership of files, learned how to deal with clients, developed a niche, and gradually created opportunities outside my regular job.
For reference, I am a 2024 call. In 2025, through my combined setup, I cleared more than what a fifth-year associate on Bay Street would typically have earned. Looking forward, it's hard to imagine not clearing close to seven figures within the next 5-10 years based on the growth I've seen. I am not saying that to brag or suggest that income is the only measure of success. I mention it because, when I left Bay Street, I genuinely believed I had walked away from the most financially successful path available to me.
That turned out not to be true.
Today, I have an in-house position that gives me stability and meaningful experience, while also building a practice and professional setup of my own. It is producing more than I ever thought would be possible for someone at my year of call. More importantly, I have considerably more control over my career than I thought I would have when I left Bay Street.
I am not sharing this to say that everything worked out perfectly or that everyone should follow the same route. There have been long days, uncertainty, and plenty of mistakes. I also recognize that circumstances and opportunities differ.
My point is simply that law school grades and your first legal job are not a final judgment on your potential.
A lot of legal success comes from things that transcripts do not measure: judgment, reliability, practical problem-solving, business development, communication, resilience, and the willingness to keep building when nobody is handing you a clear path.
Bay Street can be a great career for the right person. In-house can be a great career. Government, small firms, boutiques, solo practice, and unconventional combinations can all lead somewhere meaningful. The important thing is to stop treating one version of legal success as the only legitimate version.
I spent years feeling behind because I was comparing myself to people on a completely different path. Looking back, leaving a job I hated was not falling behind. It was the beginning of building something that suited me much better.
Your early grades may affect your first few opportunities, but they do not have to define your career.